Janna
New Member
Hey BBK,
Well, I'm going to say what I think, and I'm sure someone will have something to come back with, but I'm gonna say it anyway.
Your daughter controls you. That's that.
The tantrums, in my opinion, if she's saving them all for you, and only you, and can control them everywhere else, to me, that's manipulation. I do not believe that children that are having true, out of control of their emotion, rages, can control them. My son, Dylan, cannot. He has rages, yes. He has them everywhere. His triggers are constantly changing, and we cannot identify them. When a trigger is set off, it doesn't matter WHAT is going on, he is out of control. When his rage is over, he's exhausted, unsure of what's going on, almost "flat".
He has also had manipulative rages. "Mommy, can I have a cookie". My reply? "No, Dylan, after dinner". Rage. Not a real rage. A "if I cry long enough I'll get what I want" rage. A tantrum. To me, rage = tantrum, not the same. Rage = out of control; tantrum = manipulating. And you know what? It works. Because you know, you fought with your daughter. She threw that suit at you, and you smacked her. Wrong. You know it, you said it, shouldn't have done it. She got what she wanted. A reaction.
I firmly believe you need some serious behavior modification with your daughter. You are going to need help, yeah, she's 6, and she's totally out of control. You need to call MH/MR (Mental Health/Mental Retardation), your psychiatrist office, somewhere and ask for help. Wrap Around services, Intensive Family Services, something. Because if you don't, she is not going to improve. Spanking is not going to help her. Fighting with her is not going to help her. You have no consistent consequences. You have no consistent rules.
I hope you don't find this offensive, but you know, someone talked to me just this way about 4 years ago, and I went home and thought about it, and they were right. And that night I got Wrap Around, the best TSS I ever had, and changed my families lives for the better. Dylan was your daughter. Any single thing I asked him to do was a problem. I couldn't get him to brush his teeth. Do homework, chores. Nothing. Everything was crying, screaming, kicking. There were times I had to lay on top of him for three hours because he wouldn't shut up.
He was diagnosis'ed one time "severe ODD". In 2006, the ODD diagnosis was removed from his Axis and will never come back.
Well, I'm going to say what I think, and I'm sure someone will have something to come back with, but I'm gonna say it anyway.
Your daughter controls you. That's that.
The tantrums, in my opinion, if she's saving them all for you, and only you, and can control them everywhere else, to me, that's manipulation. I do not believe that children that are having true, out of control of their emotion, rages, can control them. My son, Dylan, cannot. He has rages, yes. He has them everywhere. His triggers are constantly changing, and we cannot identify them. When a trigger is set off, it doesn't matter WHAT is going on, he is out of control. When his rage is over, he's exhausted, unsure of what's going on, almost "flat".
He has also had manipulative rages. "Mommy, can I have a cookie". My reply? "No, Dylan, after dinner". Rage. Not a real rage. A "if I cry long enough I'll get what I want" rage. A tantrum. To me, rage = tantrum, not the same. Rage = out of control; tantrum = manipulating. And you know what? It works. Because you know, you fought with your daughter. She threw that suit at you, and you smacked her. Wrong. You know it, you said it, shouldn't have done it. She got what she wanted. A reaction.
I firmly believe you need some serious behavior modification with your daughter. You are going to need help, yeah, she's 6, and she's totally out of control. You need to call MH/MR (Mental Health/Mental Retardation), your psychiatrist office, somewhere and ask for help. Wrap Around services, Intensive Family Services, something. Because if you don't, she is not going to improve. Spanking is not going to help her. Fighting with her is not going to help her. You have no consistent consequences. You have no consistent rules.
I hope you don't find this offensive, but you know, someone talked to me just this way about 4 years ago, and I went home and thought about it, and they were right. And that night I got Wrap Around, the best TSS I ever had, and changed my families lives for the better. Dylan was your daughter. Any single thing I asked him to do was a problem. I couldn't get him to brush his teeth. Do homework, chores. Nothing. Everything was crying, screaming, kicking. There were times I had to lay on top of him for three hours because he wouldn't shut up.
He was diagnosis'ed one time "severe ODD". In 2006, the ODD diagnosis was removed from his Axis and will never come back.