I wrote a book. Thank you very much everybody.
I had written this at the end, and moved it to the top, because it is the most hopeful position I can come up with:
The trauma therapist I see thinks J should come home. She did not say so directly, but I could see she believes that. She thinks I should let M handle the situation and keep out of it. She thinks that J needs my support and she thinks that I can handle the situation. She thinks I'm changing and I am capable of way more than I think. All of this I agree with. This would be a hopeful way to think. It would be operating with the assumption that all three of us can and will do better.
Now I will go into the weeds:
Maybe I read it wrong and M doesn't judge or complain about J.
You've got it right. M judges and complains to me. (M is direct, blunt, actually.) This is his personality. *Is this anything like your husband's personality with Ben, Tired?
I can change by learning to let it go or to stand up to him (possibly). I have way more control here than I take. I give in and withdraw. That's part of the reason I don't want to live with him. It is my house, but I let him boss me around and have control. I defer. He is WAY better now that we are not living together.
If j comes home, can you let control go? If you can, great. If you are going to constantly stress and tell him what to do, forget it.
I don't drink but I think I'm going to start going to AA to learn how to let go of things and to stick up for myself. I cannot stand conflict. And, unfortunately, I do not like to face reality.
These are all personality limitations that are in me, that I can change. Maybe. (I mean, as I write this, I am thinking how realistic is it that I submit to a lobotomy in order to cope with my life?)
I am afraid that maybe Cope FEELS that she needs both of them to be ok with each other and M to be ok with J being there.
Yes and no. I am concerned that M be OK with this. If there is ongoing conflict, he will move out, which is fine. There is no real reason he has to be in the apartment. Except even though there is potential for conflict, I TRUST M. Not only do I trust him as a person, I trust him with J, despite the propensity for conflict. He loves J. And he wants the best for him.
The obvious problem with that is that M's ideas about the best for J, have not worked out. M REALLY takes control and gets bossy. M can be a hard-ass, and I am concerned that M will not let go of the idea that J must change. M has a brother who was destroyed by drugs, and M cannot be neutral about the subject.
The thing is J KNOWS M. We've already been through this several times before. Not one of us has succeeded at this. Actually, M was always the one to cede first. He was always the softest, with my son. He was the one my son went to when I would go crazy and M was always the one that behind my back would give in to my son. (I know I sound nice, and I am nice but I don't seem to cope well with interpersonal stressors, except at work. You see, I am reactive. I get hysterical. But not aggressive.) M just gives orders. He criticizes, and commands. And then it blows over and he has a lot more give in his personality. And then he is softer than I am. Because once I have lost it, I've lost it. (I'm feeling very hopeless right now.)
That said, I think that there is a reasonable chance that M will be more mellow now, because all of us have water under the bridge. I think he is beginning to see that J has real limitations, and I think it might be easier because I will not be there with them. M thinks he is protecting me. I am really a weak link here.
Personally I think my son is NOT going to come back. The weather will soon be warmer where he is. What, really, would be the incentive for him to return? He KNOWS what we're like. Why would he expect anybody has changed?
I do not know if the friend makes him PAY to stay in the truck, I hadn't thought about that (that would make me feel TERRIBLE), but my son does not much like to pay rent.
What I think is that my son WANTS to be in communication with me, but I am not all that sure he wants to come back here. I think my son considers coming back when he feels he's without options. For example, when he wanted to come back last month, it was because he felt a burden to his friend. He would want to come back if his friend said he could not sleep in the truck anymore.
And my son KNOWS M's personality. My son will KNOW what living with M will be. He will not want it. He loves M, but he knows that M will set a standard. M will expect him to be clean. And M will not be comfortable with J's smoking marijuana all day. My son will know that going in, and he will decide. I do not think my son will choose to butt heads with M. And I am not ready, yet, to say to M, leave. (I fear that without M my son will eat me for lunch.)
M's brother in law wants to live there too and there is room for all three of them, in separate rooms. M's brother in law is much more easy going than M (he's a mature working man, with two daughters a little younger than my son, I would guess he's about 50) and I think he and J would be a pretty good match. Actually, with the three of them I could see it working. Possibly.
To be honest I AM worried about dealing with J alone. I am concerned about the apartment, and his not destroying it. It is beautiful now. There are brand new floors, even. If he trashes the place, I will feel terrible. But the thing is any tenant that was not M or M's brother in law might likely trash the place. It is going to happen. I have to accept that. So. I have to be the one who changes, in any event.
What I am accepting is that there is no scenario here where I have control. None.
Thank you so very much, everybody. I am confusing myself. Again. Elsi and SWOT have completely opposite opinions and I agree with them BOTH. SWOT is right about how I suffer. Elsi is right about what triggers me. Oh Gee.