TL, thank you for that, and for pulling me back from my insistence on certainty. I know better, or certainly should know better by now. There is no certainty. There is only today.
Copa, I am sorry about your father. I am so sorry that his disease robbed him and you of the man he could have been. He made the choices he did, and you paid the price, and that's what he hated. The realization that he couldn't beat it and you paid the price. It wasn't you he hated.
I've said before that while I believe active alcoholics and addicts are real jerks, the recovering ones are some of the coolest people I know. If I were more religious and believed in the forces of good and evil, I would believe that alcoholism/addiction is how Evil keeps mankind's potential under wraps, by preventing some of our most promising from reaching their fullest.
Copa, your question about what sets this relapse apart is a good one. Now that t.l. has gotten me back into a steady state, I will try to pin this down.
In the past he has made active, targeted, (clumsy) attempts to terrify and horrify, usually to punish or manipulate us into doing something.
The difference this time is that although he didn't target us, he knew we would be terrified and out of our minds with worry, and he did NOTHING. Less than a month after this grand, prodigal-son-style reconciliation and celebration, and less than a week after his charges were dismissed.
So the thing that kept him sober was not the strength of the bonds he felt toward his family. What kept him sober was the charges hanging over his head.
The thing that brought him to the surface was not any sense of obligation to his family. It was running out of money.
I expected a relapse. What I didn't expect was for him to so quickly forget and disregard the people he's spent the last year claiming he wanted to make amends to.
As t.l. said, I don't have to make my mind up today, and I can hope that maybe the pull of his addiction will weaken a little more as time goes on. But for right now, for today, I feel like maybe it's time for me to just accept him the way he is, accept the choice he's made and stop trying to build on something that isn't there.
I also wanted to add that I've doled out a lot of advice over the years, and especially over the last year. I feel pretty foolish about it now. I want to apologize to everyone on this board for any certainty or readiness to assume things I had no business assuming.
The "nuggets" of wisdom that started this thread are good ones, I think. I didn't come up with those; they are from the guys who actually live this stuff.
If I'm not on the boards for awhile, it is because I am regrouping. I thank all of you for your support and advice over the years.