If you are a danger to society in my opinion you belong away from others.
Absolutely. It's hard when that person is your child, but I can't argue here.
I've been on practically all sides of the prison issue, short of getting arrested or serving time myself. N was in prison/jail for nine months total, including 3 months in the rehab/reentry program. C was in jail for about 3.5 weeks awaiting trial for his DV and then was just sentenced to time served. S was arrested once but then released without charge. In none of those situations did I provide bail, pay for a lawyer, or otherwise put resources on the line to help them out of their self-made messes. My kids know I play hardball on this: you call me from jail, don't expect money or sympathy. Don't bother telling me it's not your fault, there's been a mistake, etc. This was an area where I felt firmly letting them avoid the consequences of their actions, or providing sympathy, would do more harm than good.
And our kids can be reactive. Some officers, and I've personally watched this, deliberately push their buttons.
And I've seen this, too. In N's case, I witnessed first hand how he was treated by officers and the DA during the process. He was arrested on a drunk and disorderly and charged with resisting arrest and assaulting an officer. The assault was spitting, not punching or attacking with a weapon - immature defiance as much as anything. They gave him a felony for it. When they were bringing him into the courthouse, I witnessed officers and the DA laughing at and goading him and handling him very roughly. "What are you gonna do,
boy? Gonna spit on me? Still feel like a tough guy?" and worse. Getting in his face, poking him in the chest. They were clearly trying to provoke another reaction where they could slap another charge. This was a couple years after his Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI), which definitely impacted impulse control and logical thinking for him. I did inform his public defender and the courts about the Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI). No one cared. It was really hard to watch. What good did it do anyone to treat him that way at that point, when he's literally in handcuffs and being compliant? What justice did it serve? Does spitting on an officer really deserve 9 months and a felony charge? I don't know. If I had gotten him a real lawyer, the outcome probably would have been different. But I didn't. I let him face it on his own, with the public defender, and take what was given to him. In the end, prison did him good. But I still don't agree with the way I saw him treated. His wrong doesn't justify their wrongs.
I have known many good and decent officers and I appreciate all of those who put their lives on the line to keep us all safe. I also know most of them are not trained to recognize mental illness or de-escalate situations with mentally ill people. And some are not temperamentally suited to handling these kinds of situation. Smithmom, I am so, so sorry for what you had to go through.
I suppose I'm also still a bit bitter that I had no protection or support from my own abuser, since he was one of them. The entire department knew and turned their backs. I can't quite forget that. Like all humans, cops are very motivated to cover their own rears and to close ranks and protect their own. When you're on the wrong side of that equation, bad things can definitely happen.