I screamed not for help but to protest. To not accept what was happening to me. Had he continued I would have continued screaming. He did not. He did try to bully me. I did not accept that either but would not fight with him. I do not want to fight.
He must make amends and promise and abide by his word to never, ever touch you in this way, ever.He is not a bad man. He knows what he did was wrong. But that does not make it better. It makes it worse.
I asked M to help me set up a new printer I bought today. I had gotten to a certain point and did not know how to put in the ink cartridges. He was irritated and used the opportunity to criticize me relentlessly. After a certain point I told him it was OK. I will return the printer. He replied. No it is not OK. Fix it. Fix the printer. You start something, you finish it. No. I want to return it, I said.
You will finish it, he said. He grabbed my shoulder, pushed me down. I began to scream. I did so on purpose. It was a decision to draw a line. I would scream as long as he was hurting me or threatening me. He became more angry.
He left.
Over 6 years, a few times. The first time was momentous. He used to drink. He had stopped drinking for 19 years, and when he was in this country, he started drinking beer again. When we got together he pretty much stopped.Has he done this to you before? Oh Copa, it is a terrible thing.
New Leaf, he does not see me making strides. He sees the cup half empty. He sees all the way I am stuck. He sees me wasting my time doing destructive things. He sees the computer as an enemy. He sees my buying not as trying to flesh out in a material way who I am, but as completely self-destructive.I am thinking that M must be very conflicted at seeing the great strides you are making Copa.
I do not think he thinks I am changing. Although I am.He says you must change, but you are changing.
And he is afraid.
But the new me has not been manifest.he feels threatened by the new you.
Again, I think this is true, in theory. But in reality, he sees me still stagnating.He fears that you are becoming more independent and attractive to other men...
I agree, Cedar. But it is complex.Copa that there was a time when you needed that or you would not have chosen M.
I am completely in agreement, Cedar.as we come to trust ourselves Copa, the patterns we require, of our men and of ourselves, change.
Thank you, Cedar. You cannot imagine how helpful this is.Hold faith with yourself Copa, and hold faith with M.
I am really liking being Germany. I am stunned by that. I am turning into Andrea Merkel. Who knew? I like it.Maintain integrity. Stay Germany. Require of yourself the highest standards you can bear to. Kindness, compassion, honesty regarding your own motives. Trust in your decency, and in M's.
So, I just stay cool. Not go anywhere. (I mean, in myself.) Stay present. Do not write a story. Just stay open.What you needed from M is changed. He is learning what you need, too. Only you don't know yet what that is, either.
You know, I do not think that M's sister is necessarily supportive of our relationship. She likes me. But I do not necessarily think that she supports his staying with me. M does not listen to her. He tells her. He has told her that he is committed to me. She told me that. But I do not think if she could write his story he would stay with me. I think his mother have M stay with me, though.Trust yourself and trust M.
Cedar, at what point in your lives did this happen? Like how many years ago? At what point were you with your children? With your family?D H throwing our dinner over the railing, and how out of character that was? Or all the confrontations, all the anger, and the growing sense of this man's integrity
I think this is true to this extent: We have been planning to go east for about a year and a half. What has held us up is me. I think he feels that his life is on hold. Because of me. And this is true to a large extent.he is seeing these good changes in you and wants them to continue ...faster.
I think this is true. I think he has tried to be patient with my various incapacities. And fails, sometimes.He perceives any step 'backwards' as stopping...possibly forever.
This is true.He is not fully perceiving the difficulty for you
Last night and this morning I was ready to think about life without him. And how I would do it and what I would do. I think this is important to envision.
Cedar, at what point in your lives did this happen? Like how many years ago? At what point were you with your children? With your family?
Copa, it is incredibly difficult to share all of this.Over 6 years, a few times. The first time was momentous. He used to drink. He had stopped drinking for 19 years, and when he was in this country, he started drinking beer again. When we got together he pretty much stopped.
The same for hubs, and my Dad. Dad had many struggles with alcohol, not the day to day drunken images we perceive, but the once in a while all out, oh G-d I've done it again, one or two or three drinks too many and lost control of myself kind of drinking.Alcohol is very toxic to him.
This brings back a lot of memories for me Copa. You are not alone in having experienced this.I began to demand to be let out of the car on the highway. M refused. I began to scream louder. Demanding to be let out. On the highway. I began to denounce both of them calling them every word I could think of. I began to open the car doors. M slapped my face. He was trying to subdue me and to respond to the insults and what he perceived as my hysteria. I was not hysterical. I was furious. I continued. Worse. (This is very hard to write.)
He slapped my face again. I told him that if he did not let me out of the car it was kidnapping.
How strong you were, and how wonderful G-d provided a ride for you.He did. I crossed the highway on a curve. It was very, very dangerous. I could care less. He followed me. The car was left at the side of the road. Remember, this was a mountain road. There was not much there. Cars and trucks whizzed by. I walked along the side of the highway to a gas station that I knew was there. I did not know what to do. Incredibly, an acquaintance drove by. He had seen my car in the road and knew something was off. He drove me home
This is such a recent memory, Copa. I am writing about events that occurred 35 years ago, yet they are still fresh in my mind. The things he does now, more subtle, remind me that the darkness is still lurking.Eventually, M came home. I do not remember when. He was completely abject. Profoundly apologetic. He said nothing like that had ever happened to him before in his life. He never drank again. That was about 5 years ago.
Did this remind you of your experience with M Copa?When the van to take her to the program came for her the first morning, she began to scream that they were kidnapping her and that she would call Adult Protective Services. My mother was very feisty and in command as a person.
Bottom lines are important.There is something in my mother and I--a bottom line.
That is a good trait.But there is something in me. And there was something in her, that refuses to go quietly, to succumb control over self, to another.
I am sure you will not Copa. Roar, or should I say Howl.This and a million other things makes me sure that if ever confronted with true evil, I will not go quietly.
Yes, Copa it is very hard to write.You ask if he has done something like this before.
A few months ago M followed me in the hall. I felt he put his hand on my head in anger. He says he was protecting me from falling. This very much affected me because my stepfather when I was about 15 had hit me in the head from behind in a hallway banging my head against the wall. There is no way he was protecting me.
It is very hard to write this.
Yes Copa, I am there with you.New Leaf, he does not see me making strides. He sees the cup half empty. He sees all the way I am stuck. He sees me wasting my time doing destructive things. He sees the computer as an enemy. He sees my buying not as trying to flesh out in a material way who I am, but as completely self-destructive.
He must see my desire for autonomy as something completely unfathomable.
He sees, Copa.I do not think he thinks I am changing. Although I am.
Ahhhh but the perception of it is there.But the new me has not been manifest.
It is coming, and if he loves you the way I think he does, he sees it Copa. He wants it, but fears it at the same time.He sees me as having been previously strong and capable and having lost my mojo. Remember, he has seen me go to work in the fiercest of prisons throughout my state. He has seen me fly off alone to Rio several times, alone. He saw me handle my sister and the illness of my mother. He saw me handle the legal ramifications and best my law professor sister.
I do not think he sees my fledgling steps as success or change or capacity of any sort.
I agree with your interpretation, I just do not see that he sees me improving or emancipating.
This stagnating, Copa, I have thought about it. My son is 14 and going through an incredible physical growth period, eating us out of house and home, he has gotten an inch taller in two months. In this time, his brain is kind of well-gone. He does things, like leave the door open, the refrigerator door, the front door. He is clumsy and trips. He is not a careless person. I have read that when children have growth spurts, the brain goes on vacation.But in reality, he sees me still stagnating.
Yes Copa, my hubs had the same dynamics. He can be passive and accommodating, he has strength of character, but the stuff of his FOO, the numbing, comes out in bits and spurts and pieces at the weirdest times.M is an enigma in many ways. He had a passive but strong mother and an abusive father. To survive in his work he developed a somewhat passive and accommodating attitude. That is what I knew first. With a strength of character.
No, you do not have to abandon yourself, or even M, for that matter. We all make mistakes, we all act out of sorts in one way or the other.I woke up bereft. To be able to hold faith with myself, makes all the difference. I do not have to abandon myself. I can be OK. You cannot imagine the actual solace this gives me.
I like you being Germany too Copa, it is exciting, watching this transformation.I am really liking being Germany. I am stunned by that. I am turning into Andrea Merkel. Who knew? I like it.
Yes, and no. It is up to you to decide. As Cedar wrote in all of her wisdom, the boat rocks.Last night and this morning I was ready to think about life without him. And how I would do it and what I would do. I think this is important to envision.
Men do not handle pain well Copa, physical or emotional. If men had to bear children, the human race could not have survived.There is also the dynamics of the other house. He is working hard. He is in pain from crooking his neck to repair the old ceiling plaster. He feels put upon. He owns no interest in that house, but he will benefit from it. Our interactions are very difficult around issues of finance and the differential in control. For each of us and for both of us together. He is in a conflict. He knows it is the right thing to do the work. But he resents that I am not with him doing it too. And at the same time he knows there are things I must do for myself. And that I will not be all that much help to him.
And the printer was connected to the computer. And he sees the computer as the root of all evil in my life. Buying stuff. Clicking.
We all fail.I think this is true. I think he has tried to be patient with my various incapacities. And fails, sometimes.
It is as it should be. What is falling in love at our age? Would it be the passion of a 20 year old, or the great comfort of having someone by our sides. The knowledge that we are not perfect and they are not perfect and somehow making it work.I did not fall in love with M. There was no sense ever of losing control. Of fear. That had always been present before. What I felt was drawn to him. I felt safety. I felt protected. I felt somebody at my side, on my side.
I had never felt this really with anybody before. Even with my parents.
I think that even though our relationship is only 6 years old, and I was already at an advanced age, I have obeyed him.Because I no longer saw any reason to stop anything because he said so, or to take his interpretation of events over my own.
M talks about this, too. How I am aggressive and impose my will over him but do it in a different way.I realize I can be pushy and nasty sometimes in my attitude and thinking and behaviors without meaning to...and here, I thought I was ~ I excused alot of really crummy behaviors and was of thinking about my D H on my part.
Which must be what our changing does to them. If we function outside of a role or no longer accept the space they have allowed us, this changes stuff for them. Their roles are impacted. They cannot continue as they were without confusion or distress.Remember we were posting about the uncertainty in functioning outside a role?
This was M, too. I was not around when he drank to excess. But the dynamics were the same in his birth family as for your Hubs.The hubs, too had a drinking problem. He drank to get through life. He drank to numb his memories of being raised in a family so dysfunctional, a father so abusive, a mother so compliant
Yes. In a million years I would not have thought I could or would be Germany or want to be. Until Cedar told me I was. And I thought? Really? I am Germany?I like you being Germany too Copa, it is exciting, watching this transformation.
Why do you say that, Cedar?I don't know why D H stayed with me.
My goodness. I never believed that I could hold anybody. That anybody would want to be with me if they really knew me.what was it about you that made you unworthy of his constancy, in your own mind?
Well, in my case, my Dad did not stay. And then he disappeared completely. And then he destroyed himself. And when he did he denounced me as unworthy.Or was it something in him, that you think was inconsistent with constancy towards you?
I do not think I deserve constancy, because everybody important to me betrayed me in one way or another. It is a marvel that I can be constant.Or is it your vision of what a relationship is? Is constancy not part of it?
Two things come to mind. First of all, he is seeing these good changes in you and wants them to continue ...faster. He perceives any step 'backwards' as stopping...possibly forever. He wants to keep the momentum going. He is not fully perceiving the difficulty for you. You cannot just flip a switch and go, "Presto chango!"
He needs to be very patient with you and lose the daily petty criticisms. Those hurt you to the core.
Talk with him that you know that he loves you and explain how it makes you feel when he us critical, short, or grabs you. Let him know that it will never be tolerated!
He is used to going out alone. Now, although it is very wonderful for you...you are now in his perceived 'space' and he finds this strange or even threatening. He is grouchy about the primer because he wants it done quickly and the way that he would have done it.
She had protected herself in her own mind...and denied herself this wonderful opportunity.
I do not know how this story relates to my own.
I was going to say that I first became aware of the horror of this space about 7 years ago in an interaction with my son. He said something so nullifying to me that I could not bear how it felt--as if I did not exist. I think it must have catapulted me back to a pre-verbal state, where I did not have even the language to express my feelings or tell myself that I even existed apart from the person who cared for me, my Mother.to feel and be unguarded at that depth and not be afraid of being destroyed. I am not there yet, either. I think that is why we are fascinated by these questions now.
Yes. And when we were erased in their eyes, we felt as if we did not exist because it was at a point where we only existed as people through their gaze or words or touch. To be denied it deprived of as if life. We died.but even worse, what we did not see in their eyes was us. We were erased, for them to do what they did.
And by not being seen we were killed off over and over again, psychically.To have been abused is a lonely thing.
We were not seen.
And that is the heart of the hurt.
And beneath invisibility is a kind of social death. When done to adults we call it marginalizing or shunning. When it is done to an infant or toddler it kills them. They die.Invisibility, seen but discounted, is what lives beneath shame.
I like this, Cedar. Because it puts the onus right on the relationship, the conversation between two equal people. It also puts gives trust and possibility and expectation that the other will meet the challenge.To me, the phrases: "Is this really the way you want to treat your wife?" Or, "Is that what you meant to say to me? Is that what you want me to believe you think about me?"
And if sustained, death.Isn't that something. As intense as the shame response was and still is...it was a defense, a cover, for invisible.
We have posted about this, Cedar. A while back. About the sisters. Or in my case, about my sister.I am forever compromising my integrity because I don't even believe it when someone does something nasty. That is why I love ballet and martial arts.
Suppressed rage, survival, persona.In these Foo threads I realized more than I had ever permitted before, that I suppressed my rage at how I was treated as a child. Doing so was the price of surviving. I had to adopt the persona as a good little girl so that I could hold on to the idea that my parents loved me enough to take care of me. So anger got suppressed. I feared it so.
Goodness is the key. Were we able to see our goodness? I never felt, good enough.My goodness. I never believed that I could hold anybody. That anybody would want to be with me if they really knew me.
Though we had to stuff our feelings, reactions and responses to what happened to us,(each of us with our different experiences) the rage was still there. The anger of a small child knowing that what was happening was wrong, with no control in the situation to stop it. The completely absurd notion that we could not be ourselves. The having to act the role, develop the persona, for survival.I think at the heart of me was a deep rage. I did not realize that it was my own self that could not tolerate the rage in me. And that once I could see it and own it, it no longer scared me so.
I have a real, clear memory of myself at two. How could I remember that?In these Foo threads I realized more than I had ever permitted before, that I suppressed my rage at how I was treated as a child. Doing so was the price of surviving. I had to adopt the persona as a good little girl so that I could hold on to the idea that my parents loved me enough to take care of me. So anger got suppressed. I feared it so.
Yes, we were supposed to stay even keeled. There is something about even keeled. But, I think that is achieved truly, after the hard work of removing all of the layers we developed while putting on the persona.That is why my own son's anger as he grew up was so intolerable to me. I believed, I think it was me that was out of control. I took personally his anger, and reacted in kind because I felt accused as angry. Which I could not tolerate. And when I became so angry, I became angrier at him for making me so.
My Dad stayed, but in a sense, he did not. He suffered the loss of his Mom to cancer when he was a young boy. I believe he was not allowed, or able to fully address his feelings.When I was five, his little sister was in a head on collision and died. I remember all of the confusion and the muffled conversations behind my parents bedroom door. I do not think we went to my aunties funeral. Children didn't go to funerals is what my Mom said. I remember a change in my Dad. A kind of sadness, then, not. It was as if a wall went up. He walled up his heart. He was there, but he was not. My Dad was a wonderful man, hard worker, he read us bedtime stories, took us to museums and places of history, taught us the importance of education. But there was something...missing.Well, in my case, my Dad did not stay. And then he disappeared completely. And then he destroyed himself. And when he did he denounced me as unworthy.
My Dad left. He was there, but part of him, left. He was protecting himself, I think. I think he was deeply sensitive, so much so, that after these two significant losses, he decided that he shouldn't allow himself to love so completely. As he went through his series of illness, the end years, he became even more and more shut down, to me at least. I would come to visit, it was as if I wasn't there. I would quietly sit in his presence and inwardly become that little girl again, that overly sensitive child that was never enough.When my Dad left, I believed it must have been my fault. Or else he would not have left. When he died, I must have felt it was my fault, too.
Constancy, even for ourselves Copa.I do not think I deserve constancy, because everybody important to me betrayed me in one way or another. It is a marvel that I can be constant.
Special indeed. In anonymity, we do not have to fear what we write. There is an honesty to it.I am thinking that what we are doing here is writing our autobiographies. But very special ones.
Yes,the awakening.....As we think more and more clearly, we bring the adult's point of view into what was a small child's experience; a child who may not have had more than a few hundred words, and did not have experience beyond her own family and home.
The children who we remember did not exist as we see and feel them now. While they could have under other circumstances, they could not have existed in the families in which we lived. We have nurtured them together, giving them that chance to thrive which they denied themselves, in order to survive.
Yes Copa, what a beautiful thing. I am truly grateful for my unseen (physically but you are so seen through your writings) sister warriors. You cannot begin to imagine the comfort I feel.It is interesting to me that each of us came here because of grief and fear having to do with mothering. And when here found a way to mother ourselves and each other.
As I you, Copa, Feeling, Cedar. When I first came to land here, and read your responses, I marveled at your intelligence and wit, and insight. I was astonished at the depth of your conversations, the close bond, the love.I am so grateful to each of you.
That is horrible, New Leaf. Of course your mother should have stayed.OMG, who does that? Could my Mom, or somebody, not have stayed with me?
This is so hard. Of course you were not nothing.G-d forgive me, I think this is the crux at why I did not go to his death bed.
I could not bear to go one last time, and see the nothing I was, through his eyes.
Yes. I do not necessarily think he allowed himself to know or see this at the end. I think he may have used everything he had in him to defend.Because I know now, I was not nothing,
I was everything, everything he feared the most,
I was his feelings, and he could not wall me up
Yes. In my case I think what was swallowed was only rage. And beneath that: fear of abandonment, and non-existence.We are virtually throwing up all of those swallowed emotions.