It is so interesting to read this thread. We had another thread like this one time, same topic.
There are so many similarities here between descriptions of our DCs.
My Difficult Child was my second child, big baby (8 lbs. 11 oz). Had colic and formula intolerance that in total, lasted 9 months. My older son was 3.5 when Difficult Child was born. I quit my full time job at the same time Difficult Child was born to spend more time at home and started a home-based business. As stated, the first nine months were hard. He was a momma's boy and was shy. He had trouble going into new situations, preschool classes, kindergarten, etc. He was really funny or shy. Very stubborn. When we would go to buy a toy or something with grandparents, he would stand there forever because he couldn't decide. I mean forever. Finally you would get so frustrated and there would be a scene. He was really good in school, made straight A's, no acting out or behavior problems until 7th grade. He quit the band (played trumpet), but joined the soccer team and played soccer 7th - 12th grades. I think that was a saving grace. He was in the gifted class but "didn't want to be smart." He wouldn't do the work, would just sit there and stubbornly not do it. If he did it, he wouldn't turn it in. I would be called by the teachers/school and would have to go up there and sit down and try to figure out what to do "with him." One time in middle school he was paddled because he was "caught holding" a girl's gameboy-type thing. Of course he didn't do anything, was just holding it.
He graduated from h.s. on time, but with mediocre grades. His h.s. was mediocre anyway, was focused on sports, and he played soccer so that worked out. After h.s. he started dating a girl he had been friends with in h.s. They had a big romance, and she ended up enabling the heck out of him. They were together for several years. Finally, she dropped him (don't blame her a bit). I'm still in touch with her on social media. She is a nice girl and got her degree, etc., and is working in the area. In our state, we have lottery scholarships for college that everybody gets, it's "yours to lose." He lost his royally immediately. He lived at home the first semester and flunked all of his classes except one. That was a turning point. He then moved out to live with his brother, which didn't work out at all. Difficult Child was an awful roommate. Who knows what was really going on? I believed all of his lies, stories, excuses. I thought he was a late bloomer, lazy, immature, unlucky. I bought it all. So in time he had me convinced that the cigarette smoke I was smelling were his friends because you know Mom how against smoking I am (he had been quite vocal about it being a nasty habit). This, after the seats in his car were burned, ashes everywhere, he smelled like it all the time. Still I believed. then I smelled pot in my house and again he convinced me (I didn't buy it but I dropped it this time) that I was smelling things. I was the crazy one. Then he stole money out of my checking account by taking my debit card and just taking the money. When we went to visit family he stole their prescription drugs and got rip-roaring drunk. The first time he got arrested, he rear ended a car and when stopped, they saw pills in his car that weren't his. That was the visible beginning of the drop off. I know there is a lot I'm leaving out and I lot I will never know and don't want to know. Lots of lies. Lots of bewildering stuff (to me). Lots of alcohol, pills, pot and who knows what else.
I think it was hard to be him. I think growing up he didn't feel comfortable in his skin. He had friends, was invited places, but wasn't a leader unless he was class clowning. Almost like a persona he put on. He has a great smile, is wiry and strong, athletic, reddish hair, tall. He is sweet and loving. He loves animals.
Is there some sort of personality type/key attributes/profile that fits our DCs? I think there seems to be some traits that tie all of them together. It's interesting to say the least.
I remember once that a couple--friends of ours---kept both of our sons while we went out of town. When we got back, the guy said: He's the one you need to worry about, not the other one. Just saying. I kind of laughed, I thought he was kidding, but looking back, clearly he saw something I couldn't see.