I would have liked to sit down and have a conversation about him coming home but I was put on the spot
This is typical. Showing up at the door. An emergency with nowhere else to go.
Right now. This minute.
I could be charitable and say that it is because their lives are chaotic and that they are impulsive. And that's true. But it's also true that they do NOT want to have a conversation with us. They don't want us to have a voice. They don't want it to be OK for us.
They want what THEY want, when they want, how they want.
so I felt I had to lay it all on the line right then.
And then when you do, there is an explosion or you are labeled as a
, or difficult or problematic. You become the identified patient, and they, the innocent lamb. The victim. The martyr. Because. See. You're
NOT SUPPOSED TO HAVE A VOICE. There's no room here for
your voice and needs. The relationship they want with us is:
YES. That's it.
And then he said that he was ready to appreciate what he has at our house and that he will pay us rent and respect us and our rules if he could come home.
I call these "magic words." Sometimes I call these "keys to the kingdom." They are designed to open doors or to extract resources. And they work.
So. Now. What to do? It is not a good sign that he was abusive to you right off the bat. There is no reason to expect that he will have a conversion experience and change. Change does not happen like that.
What I have learned is that I HAVE NO POWER to effect ANY change in my son. Only he does. But I can change.
I want my son to take responsibility, to be a problem solver, to have goals and to meet them, and to take care of his health and mental health. All of my focus on this has led to frustration, pain and struggle.
I am learning that the way I can change is to learn to accept reality, to say NO, to live in the present, and to act from love. The problem is that these are contradictory. And I get easily confused. And then I don't know what to do. Except, there is a major advantage to this paragraph. All of these results are in me, and not in him. At least there's some hope.
I don't agree with some of the posters above. I believe that talking helps, realizing that they don't listen to our conditions and they forget them the minute they gain entry or what they want. I think the talking that helps is "I statements."
I need this because I feel that. Or.
That won't work for me. I need xx.
But that requires you first to think about and to anticipate your needs and bottom line, and most important, to follow through:
If your needs are NOT being met, change has to happen. And that usually means that they leave.
From my experience my son will attempt to turn the tables and make the problem me.
And a whole lot of the time I buy it. That is why distance has its advantages. Because with distance, they have to feel the effects of their choices and lives. They can blame us up to a point, but this gets old. Eventually they begin to see that their choices have created their reality, not their mother's choices. Hopefully.
The problem is that distance is EXTREMELY painful for some of us, namely ME. But sometimes there is no choice. I am learning the importance of having a very, very scanty bottom line. But it's hard.
I am going to see my son tomorrow (I hope he shows) and I am still not sure what will be my bottom line. What I think I will do is follow my own advice: stay in the present; act from love; don't make any decisions from pressure, etc. And another one, that I forgot. He gets to write his own life. Not me. But I get to write mine.
If he wants stuff from me, it has to work for me, and he is the one who has to make it work. Not me.
And regarding being stuck with him, if he does not make it work. Tenant law differs from state to state. I doubt he will have tenant's rights right away. In my state tenant's rights come after 28 days.
I would get one of those deadbolt locks that has a code, that can be easily changed. I would think over the next few days what is your bottom line. What you can't, won't tolerate. What you need him to do. I would be very clear. And keep to the basics. I would tell him: This is conditional and short-term. We will re-evaluate every week to see how we are doing. If he does not follow through in a major way, I would consider telling him to leave (before the 28 days, if your state is the same as my own) and I would change the code.
This is how people learn. They learn from experience. Not always. But sometimes. They don't learn from magic words. They learn from consequences.