Hey, Cedar, or anyone interested in FOO (Family of Origin) issues. Cedar, WHY NOW???

BusynMember

Well-Known Member
Copa, I think he will contact you again. I really do.

It is hard not to bring our past into our present sometimes too. I know that. Your boundary was reasonable. I am not sure how to block my phone either, but I told my dad I blocked my Things...lol. I hope I did it right, but I know you didn't mean it with your son.

Copa, nobody is less impressed by money, power, showing off, etc. than me. Nobody. My idea of an ideal life would be to travel all over the country in an RV and stop off at differen campsites, talking to the people who were there, sitting around a fire, dressed down, etc. I grew up in a fairly ritzy town and fled as soon as I could and have no good memories of the plastic cut outs who lived there. All they thought about was their possessions and what others had...ugh. I could never be that way. borrrrrrrrrrrrrring. I'm very happy in my clean, airy two bedroom apartment where we don't have to do the lawns or fix what breaks and we are at peace. There is no pressure to wear name brands. I doubt I even know most name brands, except in shoes, which I work with at goodwill and I only learned them because of Goodwill. That's m y part-time job. I never wanted to be important or the average person's idea of successful. I more enjoy the simple things in life that money can't buy or take away.

I lived in a Chicago suburb. It was not on the North Shore, which is extremely, extremely wealthy, but I did live NEAR there. I don't know if you've heard of Winnetka, Highland Park, Wilmette, Glenvew or t hat area of Chicago's burbs, but they are very very very wealthy. I heard once they were one of the wealthiest in the nation. I DON"T CARE. I would never live there, even if I won the lotto. If I did, I'd buy several vacation homes in remote areas so we could travel around and meet down-to-earth people.

There is something about wearing mink stoles (as an animal lover I hope the upper class has dropped these hideous coats) and wearing spiked high heels while walking to synagogue in the Sept. heat of Chicago that turns my stomach.

This is one reason I renounced my Jewish roots. It may be wrong, and I feel guilty telling you this, but I just could nott abide the people I grew up with and most of them were Jewish, snobbish, and made fun of me. I always tended to get along better with the very few non-Jews in my classroom and decided early on to switch religions as soon as I could, partly because the school experience, and my peers, were another source of trauma.

Copa, your sister could have all the money in the world and I wouldn't be impressed. The only way anyone can impress me is by being kind and giving and caring. Copa, the few times I've gone back to my growing up suburb to take a look at it for old times sake (and torture( it makes me want to gag.

So one person your sister can not impress with her "stuff" is me. by the way, I hate cities and live hundreds of miles from the nearest big city in Wisconsin. I like it where the crime is low and the people are friendly, not looking at the labels on your clothing.
 

BusynMember

Well-Known Member
What if he is doing what I did with my mother? That is, when she hurt me, I would stay away for years and years. And that is my punishment. Please G-d. Let it not be this. I do not deserve no contact just because I said don't make fun of my father abusing me. That would be too cruel.
I don't believe he will. When he calls, set up a lunch date and ignore his ramblings or put your phone down until you know he is done talking. Then go on to another subject. I mean...at least try it.
 

BusynMember

Well-Known Member
Urban sophisticates live a big city lifestyle, whether or not they live in or near a big city.y

Usually people like this are loaded with phonies and narcissistics. Yes, I said I wouldn't use the word again, but I'm not diagnosing anybody. I just mean people who love to look powerful and important, even if they really feel small inside. I grew up with people like this. the man across the street was very wealthy and I believe he had his own company. He hung himself by his tie. His wife found him. Yep, my mother told me, but this I think is true. I never saw him again.

"Your eyes are deceiving. Don't trust them." Ben Kenobi, Star Wars

I like down-to-earth and real.
 
Last edited:

Copabanana

Well-Known Member
if you're a regular supporter of the arts and enjoy outings to the theatre, weekend boutique-ing, or even a finely aged wine with dinner, than you're in good company with the people of the xxxx neighborhood.
SWOT, I just realized something important. I keep beating myself up with pictures of her house and descriptions of her neighborhood, to hurt myself, just as you were doing with borderline.

It is like, I cannot righteously just live a sweet, nice, loving life without bashing myself with my sister's stuff and the way she has chosen to live...which is nowhere and nothing like I live or would choose to live.

And I really, really do not understand why. Because for years and years *up until my mother's illness and death, I could really care less what she had or did not have. Actually, I was always a bit contemptuous inside myself of her materialism, her desire and need to feel better than other people...to be the 1 percent. Always, I have been the 99 percent and never would want to be otherwise.

So this reading about her neighborhood and looking at the pictures of the house or the furniture is self-abuse, too. The reason, I do not know. Because I would never want to live as she does.

Except I do understand one thing: I am forcing myself to look at what my sister values, and by that I am entering into and buying into her system of value and her place in it. And in that I am empowering her, that her that is represented inside of me, part of me where I hold her. I am yielding that space to her, I am allowing her to co-opt me, and making myself small, in her thrall. Of her high status, of her stuff. I am letting her hold me hostage for those minutes I do this. On purpose. I am allowing it.

And it makes me wonder if this is related to the same force that propels me to go back to bed, and believe this is my destiny.

SWOT, now that I write this, I realize that when you go through the motions of reviewing the borderline diagnosis, it may be similar.

You may do it to give power to your abusers, just as I am serving my sister. As a power dynamic. And we need to pay attention to the triggers. What is going on inside us and with us when we need to subordinate ourselves to them, and need to bow down to them, or take ourselves down so as to not be bigger or better than they.

stop off at differen campsites, talking to the people who were there, sitting around a fire, dressed down, etc.
SWOT. Me too. I was just looking at my small collection of cast iron dutch ovens and frying pans. Because if i ever get out of bed we want to start camping and fishing.

f I won the lotto. If I did, I'd buy several vacation homes in remote areas so we could travel around and meet down-to-earth people.
I'm right there with you, SWOT.
 
Last edited:

BusynMember

Well-Known Member
Except I do understand one thing: I am forcing myself to look at what my sister values, and by that I am entering into and buying into her system of value and her place in it. And in that I am empowering her, that her that is represented inside of me, part of me where I hold her. I am yielding that space to her, I am allowing her to co-opt me, and making myself small, in her thrall. Of her high status, of her stuff. I am letting her hold me hostage for those minutes I do this. On purpose. I am allowing it.
It is always good to take an honest look at who those who are mean to us are.

Without naming names, somebody I know threatened to divorce her husband if he didn't built her a bigger, grander house than she already had. It was not as nice as your sister's and frankly they did not have enough money to build the new house, but he obviously didn't want her to leave him (although she claims he didn't love her) and he asked his wealthy father to help them pay the mortgage on this new and fancy and unnecessary material item this person wanted to have for no reason other than to show off. She claimed it was so her kids would feel good about their house, but it was really a throwback or an emotional reaction to her past. SHE had been embarassed at OUR home, which I described, and she was going to make sure she had this nice house in this upper class area that they couldnh't afford even with two salaries.

She left him anyway.

To look for somebody she REALLY loved because they never really loved each other.

And now she has spent FIVE YEARS with somebody and REALLY learned the meaning of not being loved or even treated with respect. And he will never buy her that house or even let her move into his with him. Such irony.

That her ex got the money from his father for her demand tells me he DID love her and she is cheating. She is and was cheating herself to make the divorce seem ok. I have no doubt she didn't ever love him. She never loved anyone really. But he did love her, don't you think?

SWOT, you crave what she has because she is mean to you. If that doesn't make sense to you, think again.

I did not give the things power when they baited me with the borderline, which I started so I do admit it was great fodder for both of them to diagnose me with it. In fact, T2 said I was diagnosed with it. Um, only by me. And her. But it wasn't to give her power that got me in a tizzy. It is how she makes things up and then meanly throws them at me. I've done it to her too. We have no business talking to one another again ever. We are toxic to one another. I feel I am the nicer toxic one...lol. But she is downright mean when she is angry and Id on't want to be that way anymore and she has no power over me anymore. I know nothing of what she is up too and it feels great.l

Maybe you should consider total oblivion with your sister. It is different from NC. It means no cheating by checking FB, Zillow, delete any e-mails, tear up mailed letters, even holidlay cards. They are meant to guilt you out, not to be nice. Don't get me wrong. Thing 2 can be nice. She can be charming. "There was a little girl, who had a little curl, right in the middle of her forehead. And when she was good, she was very, very good. But when she was mean, she was horrid."

Now, to me, she is an atom. As Thing 1 used to say...a molecule.
 
Last edited:

Scent of Cedar *

Well-Known Member
I was so fragmented before that, as everyone with trauma issues is. It took so long for me to get to know me. Do you all feel the same way?

Yes. It has been an interesting life, now that I am looking back on it. It has been a life of service and warmth and arrogance and shame. And of triumph too, in creating and savoring the reality of the thing created.

Like you SWOT, loving your babies and loving the one baby, the one who could not relax into your arms, into loving himself.

That is triumph for you and for me and for Copa, too.

I wonder if that is why your mother tried so hard to destroy you there. When she said those things about money and children.

That could be, SWOT.

***

Lots of stars. Lots and lots of sun. My term for fragmented would be "external locus of control". I never felt I had ~ I don't know. I am taken by surprise alot. I love to make beautiful places, inside or outside, and I love to make that feeling of home. I love to read, and to see how others are thinking, about all kinds of things. Among the most fascinating things I have learned during this time are studies of math (even when I don't understand it in that intuitive way some people do ~ and I definitely do not) and of economics. There are so many theories out there about how to do this, about how to create enough for all of us. In math, it's the wonder of proving and predicting things that turn out to be real through mathematics. It is the relationship between mathematics and music and silence; the understanding, the glimpse of the connection in everything represented by those things.

I like it very much when things smell good.

Until I had babies, until I had someone to cherish and protect, I think I was not loyal. It was easy for me to leave, always. The harder thing, for me, was to stay; was to take responsibility, declare a value, and create a reality there.

Perhaps that is why I have trouble leaving, now.

I wish I had my years and days to live over. I wish I had known it was possible to learn and to disempower that mother within me so completely. I wish I had never seen her again, that she had been no part of my youth or my mothering.

I still love her.

I am thinking that when I am through the material on my sister, I will feel the same way about her. No trust without respect. No love without trust.

I will still love her.

That does not change who she is.

Currently, today, I am feeling responsible for holding a light, for standing on the porch waiting for my sister, to welcome her home. I think that is the imagery that must change before I can see my sister clearly.

I cannot imagine locking my door to her. (On the second reading: I refuse to. It would be more in the nature of a confrontation, now. No need to lock a freaking thing.)

That is the imagery that has to change.

I am not her mother. I am not responsible for welcoming her home. She did what she did to my daughter. That is who she really is. Whoever I think she is, whatever the imagery of homecoming and cheerful light and welcome ~ my sister is that woman who has all she needs, yet opted to hurt my child. Almost, to taunt my child with the love and acceptance and goodwill of family. It would be one thing to have turned away from her entirely ~ to have been so disgusted she set a boundary. But why pursue my child? Why take steps to be certain I would know that she knew what had happened to my child in this time when we were not hearing from anyone in my family, when they were not returning our calls or sending Christmas cards?

WTF?

It is as though she celebrated the pain and confusion and hurt and darkness of that time. Like she wanted to revel in it.

I don't get that.

She has hurt me in so many ways too, but I have not been angry with her so much as puzzled and hurt and self accusatory. When I read my old threads, that is what I see. Had I been showing off, had I been thoughtlessly stupid or cruel or had I offended in some way I could not see that would justify her actions.

All I really need to do regarding my sister is stop accusing myself.

Anyway. That is where I am this morning.

I am thinking about what Witzend posted on another thread. Witz' sister stalked her, too. It isn't enough for them somehow, that we are exiled, that we are excluded. Given my sister's response to my self-imposed exile, that we choose to turn away seems to anger the sisters. They seem to redouble their efforts to ~ I don't know what it is they want with us. Witz' sister actively sought to know where Witz and her family were. Though it was a further extreme of what each of our sisters are doing, the dynamic there is the same. If you think about it in this way, stories of this nature are contained in so much of our mythology. The reviled family member, the one who was cheated out of his birthright, the one who leaves or is sold into slavery or who is tossed into the desert, learns who he or she really is and goes on to do very well in the world. As seems to be the case for each of us, the self concept our families insist on is not reflected for us in the world outside of family. When we widen the scope, we see those same kinds of realities reflected in the lives of our sisters (or mothers) that they insist is true of and for us. We can only conclude...I don't know what to conclude.

The issues that weigh so heavily on our hearts are their issues, not ours. They see us as they see us, they will us to be as they see us. The issue for all of us, the way we are being hurt by our sisters, seems to be that we maintain a vulnerability to them, that we believe them to be other than they are, because we love them.

But could it be true that they are predators, and nothing more?

Just another stupid predator, unable to keep his or her hands off us.

***

Why do I feel that I am responsible for safe harbor? We already know my sisters rifles luggage and journals and mail. Whatever her words say, her actions indicate that she despises me. We have established that. Yet, she pursues me.

It is just a strangeness that each of our sisters seem to see us as they seem to see us.

Here is the difference: When I have someone in my life who betrays me, it takes what it takes to come back from it. After that, I am essentially immune to that person, to that kind of hurt in future, because it is easy to see. It is even easy to see it coming; it is easy to predict. But I don't actively seek them out. I don't stalk or not stalk. But our sisters seem to do that to us.

How strange.

You should have reported him.

I would never, even today. It is a personal matter. Whether he would be disciplined would make no difference to me. The hurt happened; the damage was done. Had I not loved and admired and respected him, had I not been so ridiculously grateful for the safety he represented from my mother/myself within, I would not have been vulnerable to him. I am the one who picked vulnerable. Much in the same way I pick vulnerable, here.

Heart in my throat, flying by the seat of my pants; crying.

I resent him for coming between the healing I needed to do and the safety of my children. Time was a factor. He had no right to do what he did. Had he been able to keep his mind on his job, had he behaved responsibly, the things we have done here would have been accomplished, then.

I was wrong. I should not have trusted him.

Even in the beginning of therapy, I remember being amazed that we could buy this kind of commitment to our healing from strangers. It seemed like a miracle to me that this could be so.

He was the thing that protected me from the murdering mother within.

The words he used made no sense then and make no sense, now. If I were manipulating him to beat the band...what is it I was winning, from someone who, in the therapeutic role, should have expected it, and who, to top it off, I was paying?

I don't know.

I was too ashamed to have been named in that way to have reported him when it happened.

It was awful.

I lived.

Snip.

When he turned on me, it collapsed the safety established against the murdering mother within. However badly it felt to have been betrayed in that way, I was still only dealing with my own traumas. It really had nothing to do with him, except that I was suddenly without allies in my own freaking psyche and the Red Queen was definitely in. I was alone there, echoes of his professional judgment that I was not worth protecting, that I had been judged and found wanting, added to those initial judgments made by the murdering mother.

Like all abuse, even between therapist and patient, there was nothing personal about it.

It was an enormous thing, to have been betrayed like that. It would be good to work through everything having to do with him, too. When I think of it now, I can think beyond the words: "You are a manipulator. I would never trust the compliments of someone like that." I can see now that whether he accepts my compliments is immaterial to my purpose in seeing him.

It was not supposed to be about him.

I was paying him to keep it about me.

That did not happen.

He was wrong.

But I lived.

I think that healing the initial wound, that healing those initial mother wounds, will heal his betrayal, too. He job was to save me through exploring and reseeing those wounds. He betrayed and hurt me through those same wounds, instead. Had the wounds not existed, had he not known that feeling of "fraud", that willingness to take blame, that certainty that my mother had decided my life was a mistaken thing, I would never have been vulnerable to him in the first place.

And that is where he hurt me.

Which is reprehensible.

But what is more reprehensible is that it is through those same wounds that every predator who has every tricked my into believing in them betrays me. It has always been that way. It is the wounding, the initial wounding, that matters, that must be healed.

Predators are opportunists. That is an apt descriptor for predator: opportunist.

I agree that people like him should not be doing therapy. I had painted all therapists, and certainly all male therapists, with that brush.

Perhaps that is not true.

Maybe characters with wounds similar to his are weeded out, when a person is educated to become a therapist. This person was a holistic physician.

Or perhaps, he was just a sphincter. A woman I knew during that time seemed surprised I was seeing him. She did not think it was a good idea. I had already bonded with him as therapist.

She was correct.

And worse still, that when I set a limit it is almost killing in its' power. And I do not want to hurt my son by making a limit. And I did. And it's too late to protect him.

Copa, if we do not set limits, there is no boundary for our sons to return to. That the boundary exists provides a center. Whether the boundary is observed or blown through, it is a reference point. Believe he is strong enough, Copa. That is what I think our sons (and our daughters too) need from us to believe in themselves. The only place they can learn that true thing in the way a mother can teach it is through the words and actions of the mother. It will not feel good for us because that is not the nature of the relationship we want with our sons. But as it turns out, that is the nature of the relationship they need, with us.

So we do that.

I am glad you set a limit, Copa. When our children are addicted or troubled in other ways, we are required to parent in ways we have never had to consider. Love him enough to do even that, Copa. If you sincerely believe it to have been wrong for your son's sake, then move heaven and earth to find him, and to give him what he needs. There is no right way to do this. You are his mother. You are the only one who can know what is right because you are the only person, in all the world, who loves him from the depths of a mother's heart.

And this was the first time of devastation. But this time I only went to be for maybe 6 months and had to get up to go to work.

So, I think I fear that having set a limit with my son, means I may never speak with or see him again. And worse still, that when I set a limit it is almost killing in its' power. And I do not want to hurt my son by making a limit. And I did. And it's too late to protect him.

Your son is a man, Copa. He does not need your protection. He needs you to love and believe in and depend on the strength in him. That is what was meant when we were discussing pirate moms. Don't make the addiction or the illness the important thing. Believe in your son ~ believe in every good thing you know about him. That is who he is. Addiction is a monster determined to eat him alive. If you don't remember who he is, if you don't remember that he is better than to do what he is doing...who will?

You are his mother, Copa.

You know who he is in his heart.

This is all so hard, Copa. So scary.

So, afraid that I say I will give up. I will give up everything. Pay the ultimate and highest price if the hostage is freed.

Because I am believing as I type this that going to bed I am paying a ransom. It is the price to be paid at that moment that someone dear to me be saved.

I wonder if it is something about my father...some ugly secret of abuse. I wonder if I cannot permit myself to live...able and complete...when my sister is so damaged and flawed.

And I fear it is my son.

I think I am understanding the feelings beneath these statements, Copa. Because I carried memories of my mother's repeated judgments against me in ways having to do with life and death and abandonment, claiming the right to my life, to the time of the day, to the feel of the ground beneath my feet ~ all those things seemed to be things that were mine by mistake. Happiness was a stolen moment. The reality was the howling witch that was my mother.

It would turn out that she was never a powerful person. She held the power of life and death over me when I weighed between thirty and fifty pounds. That was the only power she had and she abused even that, Copa.

That is the abuse my mother committed.

That is what we are about recovering, here.

Reclamation of our own minds, of our own right to feel happiness or deep grief or simple surprise or welcome; deeply, flexibly, present.

Mother has to go, Copa.

You are not your mother. You did not do what she did; you will never do what she did. You will be safe from the toxicity she instilled when you see her through your own eyes; when you claim the inalienable right to name yourself, and to see and know and love yourself through your own eyes, and not hers.

I'm sorry, Copa. I could be wrong in a million ways. But I think that, like mine did too, your child needs you to stand up. He needs you strong and centered and whole, lest guilt hollow him out; lest he not be strong enough to overcome his addiction.

I don't know about how to look at a sister yet. I am still working through unprocessed material regarding my own sister. But I do think I know that our sisters will hurt us. It seems they willingly hurt our children when they can do it. I do know our sisters seem determined to see us as stupidly foolish, as people without grace or intelligence or legitimacy.

So, there is that. Why we don't put them in their places, why we allow them in again and again and again...I don't know why we do that. In my look at how to do what I am determined to do regarding family of origin issues, I am waiting to see, where my sister is concerned. I remember taking that attitude with my mother, too. I continued finding evidence that eventually tilted the scales against the good things I had chosen to believe regarding my mother. I remember posting here about the hurt and surprise and stupidity of it. I love my mother, and I miss the scent and sound of her very much. But I have the incredible weight of all the things I know about her now to balance that way I feel about her. Even if I see my mother again, I will be safe from her, now.

That is where you need to get to too, Copa.

It is unpleasant.

So were our mothers; and their reigns are over.

On white horses
with reigns of braided satin black as Hell
And with white satin, for a bit


Or however that poetry went.

I loathe FB :) But this is hilarious.

I don't know what to think, SWOT. Is my sister making fun of me or of my daughter? Is she denigrating the seriousness, or the stupid ridiculousness, or the urge to self-destruction, that brought my daughter to where she was?

My sister is loved and cared for in her own home. My daughter was homeless in winter, drug addicted, hurt physically and emotionally betrayed.

I trip over this; whenever I think about my sister in relation to any part of this, I trip over it.

Cedar
 

BusynMember

Well-Known Member
I am thinking about what Witzend posted on another thread. Witz' sister stalked her, too. It isn't enough for them somehow, that we are exiled, that we are excluded. Given my sister's response to my self-imposed exile, that we choose to turn away seems to anger the sisters. They seem to redouble their efforts to ~ I don't know what it is they want with us.

Well, they have nobody to pick on and belittle and put down and cut off and hurt without us so our loss is devastating to them. Let's be honest here. They don't do it to others outside of FOO. Just to us. When we let them go, they come back, with a strong need to read our thoughts and goings on. I'll bet T2 is still reading this, if not every day, sometimes. The difference is, I don't care what she thinks. She is air in my life.

Sometimes after a parent passes on, a sibling who is needy will latch on to some family member. She did this with me until she couldn't. Now she is using Thing 1. Why? He is all that's left when my father passes on. The mother, the uncle, the grandma (who favored me anyway)...they are gone. She has to be uber-nice to T1 now, even complimenting his looks. Before I went complete oblivion, as I call it, I sometimes read his FB and she would often comment on how good he looked. That would make me smirk. She had spent our entire childhood and beyond talking about how ugly he is. Must be trying to compensate or desperately cling to him. Her kids are not home with her. Her ex husband, her roommate still, is not going to comfort her. He in no way thinks that living with her means they are together. He learned. All she has is T1.

But going back to why they stalk us...we rent more space in their heads than they rent in ours. We don't need them to belittle and torment and hang up on and shame. But they need us for that. So we are important. We make them feel better about their own pathetic selves, Cedar. On some level, they know they are severely damaged and that we are doing much better.

I am not sure why I would love T1 or T2. To me, love and respect go hand in hand. I loved them both very much, especially T2, but the love seemed to die when she told her room full of know-it-all borderline diagnosticians that I was lying about my abuse and my past. I forgave everything else, but not the invalidation. The love died an instant, quick death. As it did with T1 when I heard he was a part of it. So my main feeling toward both is a sort of "stay-away-from-me-forever apathy.

Now is T2 wants to read my point of view, I welcome her to do so, even if she disagrees with it. I have never told her t he truth about how I have felt and even if she doesn't believe it, on some level perhaps she WILL believe me if she reads enough. But I don't care if she doesn't read itt either.

I don't think she has my new address. At least not yet. I feel safe knowing this. No letters.

You have to earn my love. That is how I feel after all the work I have put into my therapy. They have earned my apathy. The stalking earned my contempt.
 

BusynMember

Well-Known Member
I don't know what to think, SWOT. Is my sister making fun of me or of my daughter? Is she denigrating the seriousness, or the stupid ridiculousness, or the urge to self-destruction, that brought my daughter to where she was?
She showed her true and ugly colors, Cedar. And as nice as your sister's environment seems, she may be less happy with her life than your daughter is in her life.

Her comment made it crystal clear who she is...you can't cheat when she posts stuff like that.
 

Scent of Cedar *

Well-Known Member
What is your sense, Cedar, of what the returning is about? Is it penance or recovery? Regressive or forward moving? Either, neither?

Innocence.

The returning is about innocence, and about believing in love, and in about believing we can create all good things with our good hearts and our good visions.

There is no penance in it. We did not view our families of origin as things that needed recovering from or ourselves as crusaders.

We loved them, just the way, after reporting the most chilling abuses, we keep saying we love them, today.

Because we do. We tend, I think, to love pretty generously, with a wide ranging sense of celebration and a belief that whatever it is we do have, it is enough and more than enough.

They are not like us.

***

When D H and I decided we should see my family of origin, I committed to creating the family I wanted for all of us. I did not understand the unremitting toxicity in them the way I do, today. Had I known then what I know about them now, I would have insisted on no contact.

It isn't that they don't know any better.

They know what they do and they mean exactly what they do.

It is just like this thing with my sister. It is exactly what it looks and feels like.
I am battling around trying to figure it out in some other way because I can't believe it could be what it looks like. But of course it is.

So that is the first reason we continue going back, the reason we continue disbelieving our own eyes, the reason we continue taking responsibility for their amoral moral outlook ~ we did not know, Copa. We thought everyone was like us. They are not like us. We thought they would change, or we thought we were wrong, or we thought we could change ourselves enough to meet them halfway.

It looked so easy, in our friends' families. That is because their mothers (and sisters) were not some version of sociopaths.

***

In posting here, I am seeing what they do, what they have done, what they choose every time and it's unbelievable.

We don't understand the living toxicity in our family lines. We have no internal reflection by which to recognize it. When we do recognize them, we still are not going to believe it could be true. That seems to be the essential nature of the conflict for me. I can't believe it. I beat myself up for thinking that way. I wonder what is the matter with me. I accuse myself of jealousy or cowardice or sour grapes. I feel ashamed. All these things Copa I do because I literally cannot convince myself that I saw what I saw, that I hear what I hear.

It's extraordinary. We do not believe that kind of evil thinking they engage in so readily ~ we don't believe that kind of thinking exists, Copa. If we thought that way, we would be horrified speechless.

We just don't see it.

We don't believe it when we do see it.

Cedar
 

Scent of Cedar *

Well-Known Member
They don't do it to others outside of FOO

Mine do. They do it to everyone. Remember my posting about the lady who drives my mother south?

The love died an instant, quick death

That is how I feel about my sister whenever I think about what she did. Maybe even about my mother. I am waiting for that to change. I don't know whether what I feel now will erupt into hatred or what will happen. hatred would be more focus than I feel right now. I am still shocked. I have that on the rim of the circle feeling. Two opposite things.

You have to earn my love. That is how I feel after all the work I have put into my therapy. They have earned my apathy. The stalking earned my contempt.

Her comment made it crystal clear who she is...you can't cheat when she posts stuff like that.

Oh, you are correct, SWOT.

I don't have to wonder what in the world is the matter with me for thinking like this. It isn't my thinking problem. It is my denial problem. I am fighting to get back to denial regarding my sister.

Thank you, SWOT.

I don't get to cheat.

It's like when I was posting about my mom. No compassion. Eyes open and keep the heat on.

I get it. I feel so much better. I was confusing myself.

I don't get to cheat.

Good one, SWOT.

Cedar


Cedar
 

BusynMember

Well-Known Member
I don't understand. Would you please explain?

Why do you love them when they treated you so badly? What qualities do they have that makes you still love them? Is it a habit? What you think is right? Do you love THEM or who you wanted them to be?

It is easy for me to look back at some times in my childhood w hen my mother was nice to me. I was in a play once and had to sing "How Lovely to be a Woman" from Bye-Bye Birdie. We did the play, actually. That was my song. I was known as a kid who was average in singing, but who really brought it home when the show was on.

That was probably my shining moment in my entire childhood. I had worked with my mother, who was very interested in this part of my life, and I brought down the house. My teacher, who was not exactly known for his nice words, stood up, clapping and said, "Now, SWOT, that was REALLY professionally! Fantastic!" And everyone went wild, including my mother. We locked eyes and I saw the pride and joy for ME. ME.

I loved that mom. I still do.

Then I remember sitting in my brother's room playing a hockey game he had and she burst in and started yelling at me. I forgot why, but brother was sitting there watching and listening. She was screaming about my selfishness and what I had done wrong THIS time. Then she went into mocking mode and started using her loud mocking voice and waving her arms as she belittled me. "I'm SWOT and I don't care about anyone in the family. But hockey, I CAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARE (long and belittling)! Stan Makita (hockey player) I CAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARE! Bobby Hull (hockey player) I CAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARE! THAT is who you care about...strangers!" I was mortified as she went on. I was also very interested in handwriting analysis and had showed her one day how generousity was shown when a person had outgoing terminals in their letters so she went after that. "Let me tell you something, HONEY, you'd better getting some OUTGOING TERMINALS IN YOUR LIFE..."

I did not recall that word for word, except t he part about the hockey players and I can still hearing her mocking me about the outgoing terminals. The little girl SWOT was feeling very small and stupid and bad. I remember t hat too because I still feel that way sometimes.

I loved that mother too, at the time, and felt, "I'm such an idiot. I always do everything wrong."

But when I look back as the adult me, I wonder if I can still love those horrible memories t hat are the reason I spent most of my life not feeling adequate and good or even nice.

I don't love who my mother was. And she IS who she WAS. So how can I say I love her? She was so cruel to me, especially after my grandmother passed away.

Are you sure what you feel is love...or the feeling that you SHOULD love your FOO?

I get confused about this too, but I have worked hard and thought a lot about it. She had reluctantly given me life. She made it clear she had not felt love for me even as an infant.

How do you two validate your love for these people who mistreated you? Perhaps it will give me a softer edge when I think of my FOO. right now I'm in full apathy mode.
 

BusynMember

Well-Known Member
Found this. Is this you? These are the symptoms of Complex Post Traumatic Stress Disorder which is caused by long-term ongoing abuse of any kind, including emotional.



Symptoms of Complex PTSD

What makes complex post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) different from other types of PTSD is that its sufferers experience prolonged trauma—such as exposure to long-term childhood abuse or long-term domestic violence—along with the consequences of chronic stress. The American Psychiatric Association’s (APA) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders lists the criteria for complex PTSD diagnosis this way:

(I) Alteration in Regulation of Affect and Impulses (for me, the answer is yes)
(A and one of B to F required)

  1. affect regulation (yes)
  2. modulation of anger (yes)
  3. self-destructive behavior
  4. suicidal preoccupation (yes)
  5. difficulty modulating sexual involvement
  6. excessive risk-taking
(II) Alterations in Attention or Consciousness
(A or B required)

  1. amnesia
  2. transient dissociative episodes and depersonalization (Yep. Had derealization/depersonalization)
(III) Alterations in Self-Perception
(Two of A to F required)

  1. ineffectiveness
  2. permanent damage
  3. guilt and responsibility yes
  4. shame YES YES YES
  5. nobody can understand YES YES YES
  6. minimizing yes
(IV) Alterations in Relations with Others
(One of A to C required)

  1. inability to trust yes
  2. revictimization yes
  3. victimizing others my sister when I was still a child, but nobody since
(V) Somatization
(Two of A to E required)

  1. problems with the digestive system yes (this is the only one)
  2. chronic pain
  3. cardiopulmonary symptoms
  4. conversion symptoms
  5. sexual symptoms
(VI) Alterations in Systems of Meaning
(A or B required)

  1. despair and hopelessness yes
  2. loss of previously sustaining beliefs
Recovery Is Possible

DO YOU HAVE COMPLEX POST TRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER:

Many who suffer from complex PTSD go years, sometimes decades, without understanding the cause of their symptoms—from sensitivity to sounds, mood dysregulation and chronic physical pain. Making the connection between their symptoms and the lived-experience of chronic stress and trauma is highly significant in the healing process. There is treatment for complex PTSD, and many people are able to overcome it.

As for Olivia, she began to read about the effects of early trauma and long-term stress and, after seeing a therapist, was properly diagnosed with the disorder. Finally having a more grounded idea as to what was “wrong,” Olivia was able to be more compassionate with herself for what she’d too long thought of as personal failures. She began to seek and find ways to reduce her stress and improve her well-being. Her journey had been long and difficult, but she was able to move out of the past and to begin focusing on a healthier, more meaningful present.

 

Scent of Cedar *

Well-Known Member
So this reading about her neighborhood and looking at the pictures of the house or the furniture is self-abuse, too. The reason, I do not know. Because I would never want to live as she does.

Could you be lonely for her, Copa? Loving someone from whom we are separated is filled with contradictions. We want to know where and how they are, and we want to know why they don't love us. We keep searching with our determined eyes to learn the mystery of love between sisters.

But our sisters don't love us, Copa.

What poops.

It is less the house and the stuff I think Copa, than a kind of imagining all that might have been. And all those endlessly circling questions about why.

The more I see what my mom and my sister have done ~ no values added, no explanations, and, as SWOT tells us all the time, NO CHEATING...I am like, tossed into a salad maker or something. I get so stuck on the "surely this can't be true" part. LIke SWOT and me, you don't get to cheat either, Copa. For the sakes of our sanity, we have to stop seeing our sisters through "that is my sister". It is a really sad thing that we don't have sisters who love us. But it is not life defining unless we allow it to be.

Snip.

My sister would have taken all the jewelry, too.

***

They are cold in their hearts, Copa.

It is a dangerous thing, to love someone like that; it is dangerous to believe someone like that loves us.

They are not like us, Copa and SWOT. They cannot be hurt by us; when they cry to us...I don't know why they do that.

This is why my therapists say I do not have borderline.

Ha! I am going to be so happy for you once you really, deep in your heart no question about it let this borderline idea go, SWOT. Your sister has been projecting, maybe. In a way, what she has done to you around the issue of borderline is similar to what that first therapist did to me. They name us something unclear, something with sharp edges, and we fill in the details. It is a very hard thing, to defend ourselves from an accusation. Like they say: "When did you stop beating your wife?"

Now, why didn't I think of that, where that first therapist is concerned.

What a wienie he was.

Oh, I am so glad to leave that behind me.

Thanks, you two.

Cedar
 

BusynMember

Well-Known Member
Thank you too, Cedar.

As time slips by and I see no hint of her existence, what she wants to think about me is irrelevant (mostly). Can't say it doesn't hurt a little. But she has never looked into Complex Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, which has borderline symptoms, but not the lack of heart. I am so 100% sure that's what it is with me and I have therapist validation in this. She brought it up. I'd never heard of this problem. It is not as well known as borderline. It is some borderline traits with a heart. I have no doubt I have a good heart. Even E. couldn't convince me otherwise, not even when I was little.

The two of you have hearts that supersede mine though. You keep loving, even after abuse, even after your eyes are wide open. I think I am too damaged or maybe too therapy-ized to love those who have shown contempt for me.

"She makes up these lies about our childhood." Or something like that.

That cut off my love in mid-stream. I can't do anything to get it back.

You two both have my admiration. I.Just.Can't.Do.It.

Here is an interesting note I remembered; a sad memory from ten years ago. Before my BFFF&F died, we used to call one another our only REAL sisters as she had sister issues too and we were so close and shared so much love and caring. She is the biggest loss of my lifetime as far as somebody who died.

Another shocking moment to me: I forgot this until just now. Wow.

I bawled like a baby when I was at her wake. It was embarassing. Even her kids were more composed so I hid to compose myself. I also bawled like a freaken baby when my mother-in-law and my ex's grandmother died (my grandmother-in-law). In fact, ex had to whisper, "STOP IT!" to me. He had a stoic family and I was crying so hard it was making a scene. I was in such a state of grief.

I did not cry a tear for mother. I don't remember crying when anyone in my family died, even my grandmother whom I loved dearly. In grandmother's case, I tried w ith success to block it out, like it had not happened and forced myself not to think about it. I did grieve later on, but not right afterward. I kept it all inside and refused to feel it. It was too overwhelming to let go and strong feelings scared me.

I have never grieved for the loss of my mother or Vain uncle. I grieved for our bad relationship and for the mother I wished she been and for how my own mother had not loved me, but not for her, the person. Uncle, well, I think right after I Heard about it and got off the phone, I went on to have a nice day.

I think it's possible all of us have complex post traumatic stress disorder. It is not the same as plain PTSD in which you had a horrific, scary experience that you can't forget. It is chronic neglect/abuse, especially at a very young age, such as infancy to three. It lives on and continues and is worse the longer you are abused. In my case, it actually did not completely stop until my sister said "It didn't happen." That's when the abuse ended as I will no longer allow her any part of my life. Ever. That was about the meanest thing anyone can say to an abuse victim. That just seemed to do it. I'm done.
 

Scent of Cedar *

Well-Known Member
Why do you love them when they treated you so badly? What qualities do they have that makes you still love them? Is it a habit? What you think is right? Do you love THEM or who you wanted them to be?

Until I read what I'd written here? I did not know they treated me badly. They did bad things. I didn't want to face it probably, that they were poops masquerading as humans. :O) Or that they were sphincters. I took responsibility for whatever it was, like I always do. Perhaps I'd been showing off when I'd invited them to Padre Island ~ remember when I posted that? I didn't see what they were doing so much as I tried to see where I'd done something to hurt them and so, they did what they did.

But that was never true.

I don't really know why I did that, SWOT. It has to do with that mothering thing, maybe.

The difference now...it isn't so much that I love them as it is that I love myself. Why should I have to harbor that rotten teeth feeling in the heart of me because my sister hates and ridicules and stalks me? Once I am sure that she is who she is, why should I let that change anything about who I am? I cannot help it that I am hated by a sister, or loved and hated both by a mother. Or maybe, that I am altogether hated by my own mother, though I don't think that is true.

Whatever they feel has nothing to do with me.

I can choose love every time. That is my right, and everyone's right. Just because they name the game hatred does not mean I need to name it hatred in any of its guises. Going through the stories here with you two taught me about how I was thinking about my sister. In a way, she was still that little girl to me. One of the things I learned is that my sister seems to define herself through being better than me, or having more than me.

Somehow, she defines herself through me in that way.

I don't know why.

Whatever the truth there for her, about which of us has more or better is not my truth and was never my question. I don't see those kinds of feelings in the relationships my friends have with their sibs. Why should I allow her (either my mother or my sister) determination to see me any way she wants to change anything about me?

I no longer believe in her. In either of them. I realize now that there was never a time when either my sister or my mother was acceptable as who she was. However we welcomed, my sister ruined it in the same way my mother has always ruined things. With my sister, it was hogging the attention and changing the dynamic through her children. The time that might have been was changed into something dull, into some boring thing that involved children and so how could we stand up and say: STOP THAT. I was always believing she didn't mean it. I was always believing she meant to be kinder. I was always believing we could do this, but we cannot because that is not her intention. She does not feel kinder toward me. She despises and hates me.

I cannot change that.

That is why there could be that feeling of celebration at what happened to my children. That is why there were so many nasty comments about the things D H and I do have. That is why my sister had or has that picture of the two of us in her bathroom. There is an unhealthy fixation, there.

But that has nothing to do with me, either.

I haven't tried to hurt her. Not in my thoughts, and not in my actions. But she has always tried to shame me. Even when we were little, even when we were adolescents, even when we were young women and moms, she ridiculed and actively hated me.

I know that, now.

Before, I was holding a space, a heartspace, for her. That is what I meant when I posted that I believed in her. As it is with my own mother (and in my thinking recently, my mother is once again my own mother ~ nothing to do with my sister, or with fantasies of women cooking together and laughing together and raising children together.

My mother is my own.

Nothing to do with my sister.

That is a difference that has happened, this morning.

Without that connection to my mother, my sister loses an inestimable amount of power. She loses the power of hope; it will never be the way I hoped it would be, between us.

So there is nothing there, then.

I am free.

What goes on between my mother and myself has nothing to do with her. I may have been harboring the belief that my mother would not behave as she has since my father's death were it not for my sister.

That is not true.

The way my mother feels about me has nothing to do with my sister.

My mother hates me all on her own steam.

But that has nothing to do with me, either.

***

Part of it ~ probably the biggest part SWOT, is that I do not want that core of hatred, that sense of cavities and rottenness associated with them, to be in me, anymore. I don't want to deny or punish or sicken or darken myself through any kind of hatred for them. I know who they are, now. It is not safe to believe in them, so now I don't. But I still believe in me.

It is possible to love them in the ways I have always loved them; it is possible to cherish good hope in those memories and to let the living person go on.

I see that in the way you think about your own sister.

You are full, filled with all you need. In the tone of your posts, I see you loving her and letting go.

What is past cannot be undone. The future will be different only in the sense that there is no open door in my heart for my sister. I will hold a door for my mother. That would be a fine thing. But like the Frenchman in the castle that Lil and Jabber posted for us here, "We already got one. Oh yes, it's very nice."

That was the thing I meant when I posted about the suffering of the Mary. How do we do that. How do we know our situations and accept them without resentment or hope.

I loved them by choice for all this time when they were being so unbelievably, cuttingly, insanely sociopathic-seeming. The strangest things were said and done, SWOT and Copa. Just as they have been in your families of origin, too. I don't want to be afraid of them or avoid them or run away from them or tell myself not to think about them. I don't want to worry about when I lose my mother. I was thinking about it this morning. That woman I post about here, that woman who is my mother, is my mother. The grown woman who is my sister has nothing to offer, nothing to give, no joy to add. Interacting with her on any level is not going to change my mother. I kept thinking we were fighting our ways through to something, some very real thing, we all wanted. But it turns out I am the only one who wanted that. Each of the other people involved in my fantasy of family wants something that looks very different than what I want.

And that's okay.

They can do that.

Our sisters hone in on our relationships to our own mothers. They insert themselves there. They talk like they have taken possession of the mothers, it seems like. This is what my sister was doing when my father was hospitalized, when my parents and I weren't speaking, when my mother wanted to marry that man. But our mothers are not idiots. Like it always is with our families of origin, our mothers know what they are doing. In reality, the sisters are separate beings altogether. There is a circle here that I am not through yet. It has to do with shame at the way my own mother sees me. And at the way my own sister sees me. It has to do with jealousy or bewilderment over the perceived desertion of me in favor of my sister. It has something to do with that tire rimming machine my mother disappeared to teach my brother she was the one who got to say whether his grandchildren mattered or not. As noted, I am not through the circle of it, yet. But it's like none of those things are real for me, anymore. How my mom thinks of me would be the same whether my sister were involved or not. How my sister sees me would be the same whether my mother were involved or not. How either of them sees my brother's grands ~ same thing. How my mother sees my sister.... Well, I haven't talked to my mom for a long time. I do not know how she sees my sister. Even if they have worked everything out and cook together in the kitchen all the time, that has nothing to do with the relationship between my mother and me, or between my sister and me.

This is an important piece of what has changed for me. I will try to describe it more succinctly once I have it more completely.

Anyway, once I could see how true all that was, both my mother and my sister diminished in size and importance and color.

Now, in my vision, there is only me and my mother.

My sister is separate from that.

I love it.

I love turning my sister into just a person, in my heart.

I don't want to hate anyone. I am not willing to make an exception for her, or for my mother.

They can feel about me any way they want to. That does not change me. It means that I will cook with other women, and my life is filled with good, strong women, with women who love to laugh and think and be where they are without all kinds of betrayals and boobie traps.

This is better.

So, that's why I love them, SWOT. I don't want to hate them, at all. I am fine; I have everything I need and more and I always did. I wanted them, but they are not the "them" I wanted. It is a better, clearer thing to be without them, to stop hoping, which gives them power over me. That was the thing I was afraid of, when I worried about them calling or coming to my door. It was as though my sister determined my relationship to my mother, somehow. What an awful feeling. I am sad for myself that I saw it that way. It is an easier thing simply to admit my mom doesn't like me very much. My sister seems not to like me at all.

But those things have nothing to do with me.

It's a good place to be, SWOT and Copa.

Cedar
 

Scent of Cedar *

Well-Known Member
The two of you have hearts that supersede mine though. You keep loving, even after abuse, even after your eyes are wide open. I think I am too damaged or maybe too therapy-ized to love those who have shown contempt for me.

I think it has to do with believing they know us better than we know ourselves. It could be that we see other families and take on the blame that our families are as wicked as they are. Just like I believed there was some value to that first therapist's condemnation. I didn't know exactly what it meant, but it slipped right exactly into what my mother (and my own little sister) seemed ~ into that feeling of hope, somehow. I was a beggar. I had so little; I created loving family. Then, when the family D H and I had created fell apart, I felt I'd lost it, that I'd messed up in some way that was so glaringly obvious but that I could not see. I felt I must have been lying, that the badness in me had been poured into my children and was destroying them. In my mind and my heart, I fell back into the toxicity of the way I was brought up. And that was a very sad thing, that this happened. I had nothing to counter the living, virulent toxicity at the heart of my family of origin. I was so desperate to figure out how I'd lost what I'd won. All I had to counter any of it was that whatever it was my mother tried to kill me for, that she hated about me, was it. It was that thing, somehow. But as we have established here through all the things we have shared, my mother was always who she is today, or she never would have done what she did to her little girls, or to her little boys, in the first place. It is still a circle for me in a way. But I have this, now: "What do you mean?"

That is the best question, ever.

I was filling in blanks all over the place when another person ~ any person ~ seemed not to be pleased with me. I need to stop filling in blanks. If something seems wrong, I need to say there is a wrong thing going on and let the pieces fall where they may. That is really all I am doing, here when I post all those terrible things that I know about my own mother or about my own sister. When I said what was wrong to my sister in that last phone conversation, she pulled out every tool that had always worked for her to put me back in that place where I blamed myself for what she was doing.

We are our own worst enemies, in the way that we do that.

I think this is true.

My own mother does hold me in contempt. The difference for me now is that I no longer believe her. My own little sister holds me in contempt, too. Like always, I am so surprised. But once we see them for who they are? We realize they don't matter. It was our hope for that family dinner, or for that time we would all be cooking in one of our kitchens ~ that was the reason what they believed mattered. Once I see them, once I see the hatred and contempt and etc ~ once I see that this is what they do in their lives to everyone in their lives ~ I can see so clearly that what they do had nothing to do with me, with who I was and have always been.

We were brought up to believe their take on things mattered more than our own. We were brought up afraid to focus on anything but our mothers.

And our mothers focused back with contempt.

And our sisters focused back with that strange mix of dependency and ridicule and questioning and listening.

There is a mixed up kind of protectiveness where our sisters are concerned. Until my sister hurt my child when she was already so hurt, I was looking at my sister as one of my children. They do things that are wrong all the time, too. But when we do dinner? We have so much fun, and the food is good and everyone laughs or cries or rages about everything we did or didn't do for them and that's okay, because D H and I know now, thanks to everyone on the site who has helped us figure it out, how to parent adult kids who are addicted or ill.

I don't see determined contempt. With everything we have all been through, there is like, a palpable joy just in hearing their voices or seeing those faces we love so much after all of it. I was thinking about Buddha baby, SWOT. Thinking about that whole concept of naming a grand Buddha baby. I really love that. Baklava grand is still here with us. It has been such a lovely thing to have her here alone with us as an adult.

A grown up Buddha baby of my own.

That is how family is supposed to feel.

Our moms, or our sisters or both, cannot feel that. That they are who they are has nothing to do with us SWOT and Copa. Nothing at all. You will love them too SWOT because that is who you already are. We only need to make that separation between taking them seriously and letting them think whatever they want.

They get to think whatever they want.

I don't know why they stalk us.

That has nothing to do with us, either.

These younger sisters of ours are not our children. How they see us doesn't need to matter. We are not their mothers. However they put the hurts of their childhoods away, it is not our responsibility to help them or fix them or nurture them. They are adults now, too.

You are like me and Copa, SWOT. You are blaming yourself for the way your sister feels about you. I did that, too. I kept dancing faster. I kept defending myself regarding how often I beat my wife.

I am the wife.

I was beating her. For the sake of some win I don't get, I was beating myself for the sake of my mom, for the sake of my sister.

I feel so sad that I did that.

Maybe that is why I kept posting that I did not get the win in what they were doing. Like if I could see where I was going wrong, I would fix it, somehow.

It would be so simple to create family with us, SWOT and Copa. Our sisters and our moms don't want that. They like the way they set it up in the beginning of their time with us, and they don't want to see those patterns changed.

That's okay.

But I am going to stop beating my wife. That is the core of the thing, for me. I was beating my wife. So were they. Now that I have stopped beating my wife, their attempts to beat her too seem like mean, small minded things. Especially given the reason I was taking them seriously, was beating my wife for their sakes, their mean small mindedness in insisting that we switch the players around but continue playing the same pointless game ~ I find that offensive, now.

I can love them, and I do. There are places in me where I loved my mom. there are places in me where I loved my sister ~ or where that was my intent.

Good for me. I love that I did that. That is who I am. That was the hope in it. The difference now is that since I am no longer beating my wife, she is not available to them for beating anymore. Neither are my children or my pets or my grass in front of my house or my husband or any of those things that are my things.

I like all my things very much.

They don't have to. They can hate me with impunity and they do.

Oh, well.

The thing is that they never had any power over me that I hadn't given them. Even that was based in hope, for me. I wanted to love them. I still do. They don't get to tell me anything about me ever again.

I see you.

I see you back.

Cedar

I have been hating them this whole time I have been posting all those terrible secret things about them right here on this site. That you would know is one thing. That I would know what they did ~ that changed everything.

***

Here is another way to see it. Love is not a competition. Love is this limitless thing, this sound of generous laughter. What we were taught of love, just like it says in Leonard Cohen's "Halleluiah" is how to shoot down someone who outdrew us. Our children taught us all the ways love is so different a thing than we'd ever tasted. To go back to Buddha baby for a minute, SWOT. How is it that our mothers had grands and did not love them, did not automatically create Buddha babies?

How could that be?

I have six. They are all Buddha babies, or they will be, when I see them again. That heartspace is there for them. All they need to do is be here in the world.

That is the difference between them and us. That is the difference between the way my sister sees and uses her children and her grand and the way I see mine. I have posted before about the performance aspect in my sister's relationship to her people.

You should see how she treats her third husband.

The day they were here making the four generation picture? My sister snapped at her husband to just go sit down. And he did it. He sat right on the sofa and he never moved until it was time for dinner.

They are in marriage counseling all the time. She names him all kinds of pseudo scientific bad names and he is never going to win. This last marriage for her is a fundamentalist Christian marriage. She found him on a fundamentalist Christian dating to get married site. Very efficient. There is no divorce and she knew that going in. He knew it too, but not in the same way. He has told her she ruins everything. He is correct. Like you and me and Copa too, he will never quite be able to figure out what it is he is doing, but he will be very sure he needs to try harder to do whatever it is that will make my sister stop crying and be happy. That is what I meant when I said we needed to see how our moms' or our sisters' other relationships are structured.

They just are who they are.

They are different than us.

Cedar

Remember when I posted about crying? And figured out that real crying is when you don't even care how you look or that you are crying? And that my sister keeps you eyes on while those beautiful eyes fill with tears.

That is manipulation.

That is who they are.

Eyes watching you, straight on, while the tears rise and flow over. Eyes watching your heart respond.

Chilling, really.

Once you see it, I mean.

Here again, if we are not someone who uses tears as a weapon? We never once suspect the other guy could be doing that to us.
 

Scent of Cedar *

Well-Known Member
Yes. But it is a strange fruit, this love. I asked M today if he thought the evil that permeates my sister is genetic. He answered, No, because if it was you would be the same and you are not.

I am very sure it is genetic. My sister is different than me. SWOT's sister is different than she is in that same generous, ingenious, kind of innocent assumption that the good will triumph way. My daughter may be what it looks like to be the genetic mix of my mother and my sister when we have been mothered well enough ~ or maybe, not quite well enough.

But my daughter has that same generous belief in the good, and that same determination to take responsibility and stand up, that I do.

She is a very good mother to her children. Even with everything that has happened to all of us, her children have that solid, well-mothered feel to them. Like in that Simon and Garfunkel song "Kodachrome".

It's like they have time.

I always feel a panicky sense of immediacy.


if I cannot permit myself to live...able and complete...when my sister is so damaged and flawed.

And I fear it is my son.

That as long as my son is floundering and vulnerable...and worst of all...that he feels I have rejected him...or I feel guilty that I have done so...and...

This is it. Again. I fear that by setting that limit with my son, telling him if he continues to disrespect me, I would think about putting a block on the phone.

M thinks I spoke too harshly, that when I am angry I speak in a voice that is not mine.

But I think this is my voice, it is just very seldom used because I fear it.

You had to take a stand, Copa. My son was getting so abusive with me, too. SWOT posted about abusive adult children. At first I couldn't see it. Then, finally, I sort of did and stood up on principle instead of trying to understand us both back to civility. What I learned from that experience is this: Our sons cannot respect themselves if they do not respect their mothers. Whether we like it or not, whether we would like to parent in that way or not, we need to be moms who are strong enough to require our sons to keep a civil tongue in their heads when they are speaking to their own mothers.

My son didn't talk to me for a long time, either.

We had also said: No money.

So, whichever thing it was that made him so angry, I just acted as though I was sorry for how it was between us. Which I was. He will sometimes begin to talk in his old way now, but not for long and not every time. In the interim, he was picked up and made to submit to random drug testing. That is probably the thing more responsible for any change in my son's behavior than anything I might have done. It was good for me to stand up though, Copa. I think it was good for you, too. There is nothing easy about any of this. It is hard to know how to see it when they want nothing to do with us.

But it was not healthy before either Copa, or you would not have searched for and found this site.

That is the thing that is so hard to remember. We always think we caused the bad things, somehow.

But we didn't.

What we did was stand up.

That was the right thing to do, Copa. Just like it was with my family of origin. They have always been snaky mean. Being nice to them didn't stop it. Being mean to them hasn't changed it. (Like when I told my sister the truth about what I was thinking instead of whatever it is I usually do.)

I am sorry your son is doing this to you. But it is true that he needs a strong mother, not a mother he can dominate and frighten.

That is a true thing, Copa.

Cedar
 

Copabanana

Well-Known Member
She left him anyway.
My sister SWOT married her last two husbands because each had something she wanted. I think of the term "harvesting" in the sense of harvesting organs from people, alive or dead.

Curiously, I think the most real relationship she ever had was with my mother.

Until I had babies, until I had someone to cherish and protect, I think I was not loyal. It was easy for me to leave, always. The harder thing, for me, was to stay; was to take responsibility, declare a value, and create a reality there.
I think that is why I am having such a hard time now. I can't leave my son. I don't want to leave M. At the end I could not leave my Mother. I was a runner, too.

It is as though she celebrated the pain and confusion and hurt and darkness of that time. Like she wanted to revel in it.
I think your sister did want to revel in the pain and degradation of your daughter, as a stand-in for you, kind of like a sorcerer's doll with voodoo pins.

The reality was the howling witch that was my mother.
My Mother, too, Cedar. I doubt myself so much. Because I think I should have understood in the later years how much she was trying to have a relationship with me. And when she would turn into a howling witch, I just removed myself immediately and did not go back for years.

But the thing I realize now, just this moment, is that the howling witch she was in my childhood, when I needed her to be different because I had no other option, no way to leave although I wanted to had imprinted itself in my psyche. And when even for a second she would do it decades later, reminded me of who she had been and still could be.

Against whom I would never develop any defenses. And I think it was a conscious choice not to develop them and I am not certain why. I am not certain if it was to protect my own innocence or to protect the vision of her as lovable. I wanted to love my mother and I still want to. What has to stop is this binary sense of things, that it is either them or us. Rather than, what is true.

You will be safe from the toxicity she instilled when you see her through your own eyes; when you claim the inalienable right to name yourself, and to see and know and love yourself through your own eyes, and not hers.
This is what I am struggling with below. How to do this, Cedar?

She showed her true and ugly colors, Cedar. And as nice as your sister's environment seems, she may be less happy with her life than your daughter is in her life.
I agree, completely, with SWOT. Your daughter has fought to be authentic. Your sister is a phantom.

We thought everyone was like us. They are not like us. We thought they would change, or we thought we were wrong
I always knew what my sister was. And I stayed as far away from her as I could. The thing was is that nobody ever believed me. Ever. So, I doubted myself. I felt that something was wrong with me, that I felt that way. While I knew, and acted as if those things I knew were true, I discounted my knowing. That having perceived as I did those things, was somehow disordered about me. That if I was a healthier or more well-adjusted or less damaged person I would see and experience my sister's actions or lifestyle or cruelties or distortions as somehow less bad or even as neutral or good.

It goes back to your insistence on seeing. That kind of seeing implies seeing and knowing and honoring and acting upon what you see...without corroboration and without verification...a relationship with yourself...that is based upon complete respect and love.

The family relationships we had are based upon honoring lies. It is okay if I steal from you. It is okay that I bully you. It is okay if I make fun of your victimization (I am remembering now that my sister loved it when I was targeted and beaten and treated sadistically by my step-father. So this amplifies my understanding of why it so affected me when my son taunted my abuse at the hands of my father.)

These family relationships establish as rules, that their pretending must be believed, that their explanations and justifications be believed and honored as real, their assertions about us are true.

They can treat us in any way they want. Hysterical. Deranged. Bitter. Abusive. That does not count. To them. It must be forgotten.

Their illusions of reality are what is real, and to them, that is all that count. And their command, "this is true, I say," makes it so.

So, even though I have known for decades to stay away from my sister, and acted on this knowing, if the truth be told, I acted "as if" because I never, ever really accepted as true what I knew, because I discredited my own perceptions in favor of her mandates. I never stopped seeing myself and her through her eyes, according to her system of value, not my own.

Why is this so? Why could I see who she was, and trust my perceptions but never go that final, necessary step? Was it because I needed to continue to elevate her, to allow her that protected status that she insists upon and I persist in allowing her to maintain?

There is an image I have of our relationship, hers and mine, that I have held for years and years. It is the sense that at any moment I want I can swat her down, like a lion swats down a cub who is acting too big for his britches. And, like that, regain their dominance.

So, I knew what she was doing, always. And I knew I could control her. The question, why did I need to perpetuate the fiction of her power??? When I have always known she was a sham. A pretender. And that I was the one who had the real strength and personal power. And so did my Mother.

Over and over again I have bought into others' system of value, diminishing my own. A traitor to myself.

And now I am thinking about M and my relationship with him. The Psychiatrist I have been talking to every couple of weeks, (I have wanted to stop as long as I have been doing so, but cannot seem to get there), made the comment, "most women would not tolerate being in a relationship like yours." By this he was referring to our different economic positions, his financial dependence upon me, and his status. And I do not' know how to put into words, what the psychiatrist's judgment means to me. And why I have not so far not stopped buying into and empowering his values and judgment over my own.

And I do not quite know how to explain how the realness of what exists between M and I somehow was what I was seeking...and it has something to do with what is my system of value...as opposed to those which I subordinate myself to, of others like that of my sister...and then lose myself. Sometimes for years and years. In important ways.

I sometimes fear that what has happened to me in these last 2 years, is that I actually try to die like my mother, or that I come to perceive myself as suffering in a way similar to how I think my son is similarly affected. It is as if there is an identification with them, on some deep level.

And why I do this is not clear to me. To restore them to as they were in my eyes. Guilt, that I suffer the same penalty and fate as do they. And why?

So back to my sister. There is the sense that I give her rein. Like I am the the rider, the leader and I decide I will let her exercise her strength...at my pleasure. Always believing that at any moment that I want I can cut her off. Stop her. Cut her down. Even destroy her. And if this is the truth, this is a whole lot of power to feel that you have. And perhaps this is a clue to why I can see her, and I can know who she is, and I can act on this knowing, while at the same time, I let her have the power. Because if you believe you can destroy somebody....you are the one who needs to be restricted, limited.

So, how does one develop the discipline of always seeing, really seeing and acting and empowering themselves based upon their own system of value, not that of another or of others? What could be the habits or practices that could further this?

When we do recognize them, we still are not going to believe it could be true. That seems to be the essential nature of the conflict for me. I can't believe it.
I would like to know if we are doing the same thing here, Cedar, and using different words to understand it, or if it is different.

I know what I see of my sister is true, and always has been. I trust my perceptions and I act on them. But when it comes to looking at her in relation to me I just devalue myself and my perceptions. And I know that this is play-acting, I mean, I know that my perceptions and seeing is 100 percent accurate. Of this I am certain. I have always trusted it. But I make the clear-eyed decision to empower others. Until I decide in one second that it is enough.

And if the truth be told, inside my self, I delight in the joke that I can win over her at any moment I decide to. But the real joke is against me. Because I choose over and over again to give up my power and my value vis a vis her. Because I privilege her need to be above me and more powerful than I. And I seem to do it with many other people, too. Except with M I do not, of that I am fairly sure.

I felt I must have been lying, that the badness in me had been poured into my children and was destroying them. In my mind and my heart, I fell back into the toxicity of the way I was brought up.

I was filling in blanks all over the place when another person ~ any person ~ seemed not to be pleased with me. I need to stop filling in blanks.
I know this way of being Cedar. Way too well. I feel anxious if somebody looks bored, or mad, or fill in any negatively tinged adjective. And I will debase myself to restore their pleasure. And as I type this I wonder if this is what I do with my sister, even from thousands of miles and years away...because this is what I do. And I wonder if this is what I am doing by feeling tired all the time and needing to be in bed. And feeling gray and used up...and old. I am debasing my value to atone, for causing somebody to feel bad.

And as I type this I believe it was my mother. It was at her feet that I learned this, how to discredit myself, debase myself and my needs, to make her happier, less mad.

If something seems wrong, I need to say there is a wrong thing going on and let the pieces fall where they may.
But Cedar, this absolutely terrifies me. Because I had a therapist experience too. And I could not let the pieces fall, because the pieces were me. I let myself need him. And when I did, and I saw he was a fraud yet could not really see it, I was already in too deep. I came to believe that without him I was Humpty Dumpty. Even though I knew I was the stronger. With him, too, I maintained the fiction that I was the weaker and the needier, to protect him.

My own little sister holds me in contempt, too. Like always, I am so surprised.
Why? That is who she is, Cedar. This is what she does. It has nothing in the world to do you. Does a tiger have stripes? When he wants to eat you does he meditate about it?

I kept defending myself regarding how often I beat my wife.

I am the wife.

I was beating her. For the sake of some win I don't get, I was beating myself for the sake of my mom, for the sake of my sister.
Cedar, I see here that we do the same thing. We take on their perspective, their point of view, to protect them, at the expense of ourselves.

Who is the ransom paid to, Copa?
I believe, Cedar, that the ransom has been payed to my mother. And still is.
I love my mother, and I miss the scent and sound of her very much. But I have the incredible weight of all the things I know about her now
Cedar, I always knew about my mother. There was no lying and no cheating. The problem is this: What if you decide to devalue what you know? What if you decide to accept their system of value, that you are less, matter less? And you do it to protect yourself, because that is the only way you can survive. Because they have something you need. Whether protection, or existence. Or even worse, because despite everything that has been shown to be so...about your strength or courage or resilience, there is something in you that has been so humiliated or defeated or destroyed...that when you get a signal...from inside yourself or your environment...that you accept as real and you are willing to die or kill yourself or execute some command (against your will and without your conscious consent...like a spy movie where the protagonist is programmed or implanted with something that tells them to kill).

And how do you resurrect and reclaim this co-opted part of you?


My life now is pretty good. If I could never leave here there would be enough....Except, I am desperate because I know that I am still responding to this kill signal. And it is this that I am desperate to reverse. Because I do not want to be the living dead.


So, I think if I can only Tango, or walk in a big urban city, or be mobile...if I can only do the things I did when I did not allow myself to be co-opted....the years I lived abroad and shortly afterwards before I went back to work. Oh why did I work so long...I see this as such a mistake. But when I am thinking about Tango and losing weight and going thousands of miles away...I am feeling desperate. (Even if I really want to do these things. And I do.)

The key is turning off the mechanism that I have introjected...the capacity and motivation to kill myself off....in accordance to signals initially learned from my mother, who I loved enough to do it.

Yesterday I went to Costco and asked where my son is doing his shopping. He has shopped 3 times here in the town where I live. That he is still here and that he is buying food, continuing as he has been gives me some peace. I will drive by the general area where I think he may be living to see if I spot him. Thank you all for sticking with me.

COPA
 
Last edited:

Scent of Cedar *

Well-Known Member
How do you two validate your love for these people who mistreated you? Perhaps it will give me a softer edge when I think of my FOO. right now I'm in full apathy mode.

It's like when we were talking about our difficult child adult kids, SWOT. And we all concluded that though the kids were so changed, we all took such great joy still in remembering this or that thing about them when they were little kids.

No one can take that away from us.

It's the same thing with our moms and sisters, I think. Whatever they thought they were doing, there were times when they seemed so sweet and funny and brilliant to me. Those are the places that shine, for me. I want those times. I claim those times. That I also know now that they are sick individuals is just a fact. A fact that frees me from believing what they did was my fault. So I feel happy to know they are like, heartless sphincters. But I had some fine times with them that were mostly times I thought were leading to being relaxed with one another. That never happened, of course.

SWOT I AM SO PROUD FOR YOU ABOUT THE MUSICAL PERFORMANCE!!!

I love it that you did that, and that your mom was so proud and happy. It broke my heart to hear about the hockey incident. About what your mom said in front of your brother.

She couldn't even let you have your own brother.

Why do you suppose she did those things, SWOT? If you take away why she said she did them ~ which we know was a lie because all abusive moms force their children to believe they deserve whatever it is the abusive mom needs to do. She must have been very jealous of you, SWOT. My D H would always say my mother and my sister too were jealous of me. I just never could see that. It could be that a twisted kind of jealousy would be a the heart of what your mom did.

That was so awful, SWOT.

It hurt me just to read it.

I don't know what I would have been able to do to recover myself if my mother destroyed me with words I remembered and believed about myself. I just have the looks and those same things about my thinking not being right. It's like my mom would go eyeless with rage. Like she would go to a place where she did not have words to call us.

We were lucky in that. Look what that stupid first therapist did with a label. I couldn't make heads nor tails of that, either. Why would he say it if it weren't true? He was a professional person. I was a patient of a professional person. So of course I had to take what he said seriously. But I could not put the pieces together of what he could possibly mean.

That is a little like what is happening with your mother's words too, SWOT.

If she said it, it must be true.

But here is the thing. Manipulator (in my case) and stupid or selfish or thinking we are pretty or in love (like in your case) those things are all judgement calls. If I were manipulating through compliments, I would know I did that. If you were any of the things your mom labeled you, you would know that. It would not feel unfair, like you weren't getting it.

That is what the flavor of leftover abuse is, I think.

That feeling that we don't know what they meant and we cannot, for the life of us, figure out what they were trying to tell us that was important enough for it to have been said in such sneering, contemptuous or triumphant (first therapist here) ways.

There is nothing selfish in your posts, SWOT. There is a generosity of spirit. You are honest when that is what will help the poster and quietly supportive when that is what will help.

I remember when it was so hard for me to believe my own mom could be lying, because that would make her a liar.

I kept tripping over that.

Cedar
 
Top