It's so hard to find a happy medium, a way to get past the hurt and just have any kind of relationship. I tend to end up in the drama because I keep responding, offering advice, offering reminders. I need to stop.
Your child is twenty. I would be doing everything the same way you are. That you do these things now, while he truly is young enough to turn everything around, will help you stand your ground if things get tougher in future. Each of us needs to do what feels right for us because sure as anything, we are going to be facing ourselves in a mirror somewhere one day saying, "What if I'd...."
We have to be able to face ourselves. Ten years from now, we have to be able to know we did the right thing as we believed the right thing to be. Because there may not be a good outcome, somewhere along the line. I know everyone hates when I talk like that. But I have had it happen, to me. So I know what I am talking about.
It is never wrong to try when a child is young. It gets to be enabling when we have been through it and through it already, or when we know for sure we are dealing with an addiction, and we keep doing the same things all over again. What I hear in your posts Lil is frustration that your son is not taking full advantage of the paths you have opened for him. I do not hear resentment from you that you have made those paths available. So bless yourself and do what your heart decrees.
Enabling is when we have made their paths so many times that we resent making the path again. Enabling, from what I can figure out and it seems like I might be the only one who sees it this way, is when we feel so done helping, but we try again anyway, resenting the stuffings out of it the whole time.
I think twenty is when we still try with our whole hearts. Unless it's an addiction. If D H and I had not tried with our whole hearts and these things still happened (which they would have, because now we know the underpinnings of our situation) I would not have been able to stand on my integrity and practice detachment without believing in it when I finally took that leap. I knew there was nothing, nothing at all, that I hadn't tried.
But you know where all that got our family. Each of us has to get there, to that place that works for our own family, on our own.
What would work to motivate this child? That's the only thing that matters, here. For right now, that is the only thing. Would it help him if you said something like:
Clarification Family Conference. Set a time limit. Create an agenda. There is time for him. There is time for you. There is response time and then, the conference is over. Have one every week, if you like, before Game of Thrones.
1) Describe (really briefly) the paths available to him. You can even say: "The paths I opened for you." You would not be remiss in this. Without your intervention, your child would have spent a brutally cold winter living in shelters or worse. He would be saddled with fines or probation or worse for the things he has done, for the acts he has committed. Or he may have stolen you blind, or a thousand other things.
So, given all those things that might have been, you are all doing really well. This is a true thing, and you and Jabber need to give yourselves credit where credit is most assuredly due. There is every possibility he will do Job Corps and it will help him. The clarification I think needs to happen is the part about what your son has decided to do if he does not stick with Job Corps or finish his community service. This clarification is necessary for your peace of mind and for no other reason. I think I hear him rebelling against mom in not doing the community service. So don't present it that way. You can be honestly curious about what he plans to do instead. You can even say something like: You are an adult. I get that. I am a mother. Ease my mind.
Either he has a plan, or he is planning on Job Corps. If he is not planning on Job Corps, what is his plan? If he chooses not to discuss it with you
let go. If he has no plan, let go. He may choose to be homeless right where he is. Until you know, you don't know.
Let go.
You have done what you can, everything you need to do to be able to meet your own eyes in the mirror, and he has asked you to butt out.
That is what you and Jabber need: To be able to meet your own eyes in the mirror. That is your only objective.
Don't catastrophize. At twenty, whether he has learned to make friends or not cannot be something you are involved in.
Let go. At twenty, playing on your maternal instincts is a manipulation, Lil. For your child's sake, recognize it as such and confront it: "We all have days like that, honey. It's what being an adult is about. Bad things and good things and standing up to both. You can do this."
Then,
let go. Unless a better response comes up, you already know how to respond to those kinds of conversations. Good. One less thing.
I guess that is what I am seeing, Lil. You are a good, strong mom. I love the way you get all cranky when you haven't eaten and then, you are back to yourself when you have.
That was so real.
So basically, you and Jabber are batting a thousand as parents. Your son is not picking up and you can't make him. You can talk to him about these things, you can have him over for the celebration of food and togetherness that is what family is all about but when you do, let it be from a sense of curiosity and goodwill. You could even say that as a family, issues regarding the future will only be discussed at Family Clarification Conference.
You could do a decision tree. You know, where you draw a tree, and they see how this choice branches out and how a different choice branches out. My kids did an eye roll on all things having to do with decision trees. What they wanted was money. That is all they wanted, every time. So, for me and for them, cutting off the money was what needed to happen for them to stand up. There was no need to manipulate me, because NO MONEY took away the need to manipulate me.
This next thing I am going to post might offend you. How involved is your son with drug use? Our son was "using recreationally". What I didn't know and refused to see is that the recreational use was daily, and the recreational drugs were acid, meth, cocaine, and whatever that cocaine substitute drug was that poor people use. My son was absolutely offended that I believed he was on whatever that one was. That is where I learned only poor people use it. Crack, I think it was. For our son, though I had it worked out in a thousand ways how his problems were a direct response to the problems at home during his teens, the problem was drugs.
That's it. There was no other problem.
So I would like you to take a second look at that, because if the core problem is drug use, then that is where you need to be applying your attention now, while he is young. I think some intellectual or emotional deficit would not lead a child to steal from his parents.
So I would like you to take a look at that drug piece again.
You know that, like all of us here on the site, I am pulling for you and your family to come through this quickly, and in one intact piece, Lil and Jabber.
Cedar
This is something my father told me regarding our son. I was like, all over the place trying to figure out why he "couldn't" take advantage of what his father and I had to offer him. He was like, blazingly brilliant. No one else seemed to see this? But I am his mother and I know this is true.
:O)
Where was I. So. My father said: "You know? I am an old man. Who is to say, at the end of a life, whether it should have been spent working and doing the responsible thing and squeezing in the things we enjoy, or blowing all that off?
If difficult child were not happy doing what he is doing, he would do something else."
Comfort. I was able to take some comfort there.